Supreme Court Justice forwards PHS's ADPF 563 to the presidency.

Editor's Blog | 26.03.19

By: Elaine Silva

Share:
Supreme Court Justice Edson Fachin has ordered that the Claim of Non-Compliance with Fundamental Precept – ADPF 563, filed by the Humanist Party of Solidarity (PHS), be sent to the presidency of the Supreme Court.

Supreme Court Justice Edson Fachin has ordered that the Claim of Non-Compliance with Fundamental Precept – ADPF 563, filed by the Humanist Party of Solidarity (PHS), be referred to the presidency of the Supreme Court.

The ADPF (Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental - Claim of Non-Compliance with a Fundamental Precept) requests that the STF (Supreme Federal Court) declare that Article 50 of Decree-Law No. 3.688 of 1941 (Law of Criminal Offenses) and Decree-Law No. 9.215 of 1946 were not received by the 1988 Constitution, as they created a state monopoly in the exploitation of gambling, offending fundamental rights and freedoms (CRFB, Article 5, caput and XLI), the principles of the economic order of free initiative (CRFB, Article 170, caput, IV, and sole paragraph) and the rules of direct exploitation of economic activity by the State (CRFB, Article 173).

According to the rapporteur, there is legitimacy for the ADPF (Action for Declaration of Unconstitutionality by Omission) to be filed in the discussion of the non-reception of normative acts, and he also notes that the issue has already been recognized in the General Repercussion of the matter in RE No. 966.177, under the jurisdiction of rapporteur Minister Luiz Fux. Fachin also notes that there was no express statement regarding the request for distribution by jurisdiction by Minister Luiz Fux during the judicial recess. "Thus, pursuant to Article 69 of the RISTF (Internal Rules of the Supreme Federal Court), I order the referral to the Presidency of the Supreme Federal Court," determines rapporteur Minister Edson Fachin.

Comment: redistribution to Minister Fux

Article 69 of the Internal Regulations of the STF (Supreme Federal Court) stipulates that "the distribution of an action or appeal creates a precedent for all processes linked to them by connection or contiguity."

In January of this year, lawyer and former judge of the TJ-SP (Court of Justice of São Paulo), Regis de Oliveira, had predicted that ADPF 563, proposed by the PHS (Humanist Party of Solidarity), could be redistributed to Minister Luiz Fux, rapporteur of RE 966.177, which has had recognition of general repercussion since June 2017.

BRLot - Online Luck - 728 x 90 1BRLot - Online Luck - 728 x 90

Share: