On TV 247, Murilo Hidalgo states that the debt does not stem from betting and calls the ban a "self-inflicted wound."

Bets I 17.10.26

By: Magno José

Share:
In an interview with Leonardo Attuch, Murilo Hidalgo states that the government attributed a debt to betting companies stemming from a tight budget and high interest rates, and that the Betting Provisional Measure affected clubs and organized fan groups, harming Lula in the first round of elections.

The ban on sports betting and online gambling was a "self-inflicted wound" for President Lula. This assessment comes from Murilo Hidalgo, director of Paraná Pesquisas, in an interview with journalist Leonardo Attuch, founder of the Brasil 247 portal and TV 247, a media outlet aligned with the PT and the president. The conversation was recorded on Tuesday (October 6th), two days after the first round of voting, in which Flávio Bolsonaro (PL) finished about two points ahead of Lula in valid votes.

It was Attuch himself who brought the topic up, asking Hidalgo what impact the bets had been on the election. The answer came without hesitation.

“A self-inflicted wound. Let me explain. The proof that it was a self-inflicted wound: President Lula announces it on a Friday and never speaks about the bets again. The betting issue is dead,” said the researcher, referring to the announcement of Provisional Measure No. 1.394/2026, made on September 25, nine days before the first round of voting.

"They told him that the debt is because of the bets."

According to Hidalgo, the fundamental error was the diagnosis that reached the president. "They told him that Brazilians' debt is because of gambling. It's not because of gambling. Gambling is one of the reasons," he stated.

The director of Paraná Pesquisas cited surveys from his own institute showing that between 75% and 80% of those who gamble do so for fun, not out of addiction. He then used comparisons to illustrate what he considers disproportionate in the measure: “It’s the same as saying: let’s end Caixa’s lotteries, because 10%, 20% are addicted to them. It’s like ending beer, for example. I like to drink beer.” Attuch agreed: “Exactly. Let’s end beer.”

Hidalgo also pointed out an effect that, in his assessment, the government did not foresee. "It was a rash action by President Lula, and especially they didn't expect it to affect the organized football fan groups, to affect the football teams. That's why, in my view, it was a self-inflicted wound."

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Murilo Hidalgo (@murilohidalgo)

The debt has another origin.

Next, Attuch asked if those in debt attribute their debts to gambling. Hidalgo was direct: "For other reasons." According to him, all the research points to the same main reason. "The money doesn't last until the end of the month. Every month the person gets into debt by R$50, R$60, R$80. When the end of the month arrives, the accounts aren't balancing. That's the big problem."

Attuch then suggested another explanation, recurrent in the president's discourse, that of stimulating consumption and excessive consumerism. Hidalgo acknowledged the phenomenon, but treated it as global and linked to the ease of credit, which he considered a success of the government. And he ruled out cutting credit as a solution. For him, what weighs against Lula is something else: “The biggest problem today is showing a way to solve people's debt. What are those who owe money today complaining about? They can't pay because of the interest rates, which are very high.”

In the same interview, Hidalgo listed the three factors that, according to the institute's quantitative and qualitative research, led Flávio to finish ahead: the economy (debt and supermarket prices), public safety, and the crisis involving the Supreme Federal Court. The bets do not appear as a cause of the debt, but as a strategic error.

Research as the basis of measurement.

The assessment contrasts with the logic that underpinned the provisional measure. On the eve of the announcement, an Atlas/Bloomberg poll indicated 75% support for the ban, and the campaign began associating the opponent with gambling with the slogan "Flávio is a bet. Lula is the way." After the first round, reports from Estadão, Folha, CNN Brasil, and O Globo noted that members of the campaign itself began to see the measure as one of the mistakes of the final stretch.

Hidalgo cautioned that the race is not yet decided. The two-point difference is reversible, and the second-round debates should be decisive. But he predicted that the first polls would show Flávio ahead by more than the margin of error, and summarized: "At this moment, Flávio Bolsonaro is the favorite."

The weight of the statement lies in where it was made. In one of the main channels of the press aligned with the government, a director of an institute that was among those that came closest to the 2022 result said, with data from his own research, that the government was wrong to blame the bets for household debt.

Watch the full interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxcNDB-Fqeg

 

EGT - 728 x 90EGT - 1280 x 90 1

Share: