Opinion: The Executive and Legislative branches understood that gambling is an economic activity and that there is a 'social fact' to be addressed.

In 2014, there was a strong reaction when Italy announced that wealth generated by illegal activities, such as prostitution, drug trafficking, and the smuggling of cigarettes and alcohol, would be included in the calculation of Gross Domestic Product (GDP, the sum of goods and services produced in a country), as directed by the European Union to facilitate comparisons of the performance of the bloc's economies.
Here in Brazil, the news that the Ministry of Finance does not intend to create new taxes, but rather tax sectors that are currently not taxed, such as sports betting and gambling, was well received by analysts and the mainstream media.
Journalist Fernando Gabeira said on Globonews that "after Haddad defended taxing sectors that are not currently taxed, the minister will discover several that fit into this scenario, such as sports betting."
Little by little, Brazil is discovering what BNL subscribers have known for many years: that any prohibition is almost always useless, as it solves nothing, just as it did not solve the issue of gambling in the country and revealed the failure of the prohibitive model.
The country has definitely understood that instead of burdening workers and businesses with taxes, political actors should discuss the possibility of regulating unregulated gambling.
Within this new understanding and favorable political scenario, the Executive and Legislative branches decided that the true challenge of the game is the creation and establishment of laws and regulations that allow citizens to exercise their desire to gamble under the watchful eye of rules clearly defined by the State and their effective application.
Expectation vs. Reality
Based on the understanding of the need to tax sectors that are currently not taxed, we must clarify that the Executive and Legislative branches cannot be selective in favoring economic groups and creating a gambling monopoly for American corporations by legalizing only casinos in integrated resorts.
As a first step, the regulation of sports betting is a good indicator, but this modality alone does not meet the government's economic needs. Without online games (casino, bingo, slot machines and Aviator), fixed-odds betting represents a third of the expected tax revenue.
A country's gambling market potential is equivalent to 1% of its Gross Domestic Product, depending on population characteristics and betting culture. Based on the 2022 GDP, Brazil has a potential of R$ 99 billion in betting, which, if taxed, could generate around R$ 25 billion per year. This value does not include licenses, investments, and job creation in the establishment of these gambling and betting establishments.
Bill 2234/2022 (PL 442/91), currently under consideration in the Senate, partially addresses the potential revenue gains from legalizing casinos in resorts, bingo, the jogo do bicho (a type of illegal lottery), and online gambling. The proposal, approved by the Chamber of Deputies in 2022, restricts the operation of casinos in resorts and licenses for jogo do bicho, but does not include slot machines, which should also be legalized and regulated by the State.
Currently, there are over 600 slot machines scattered throughout the country, which could increase revenue by at least R$ 3 billion every year. Furthermore, if the government charged a license fee of R$ 1,5 per machine, it would generate revenue of approximately R$ 1 billion. Even if they are not included in the legalization project, they will not cease to exist because there is demand, and with criminalization, they will migrate from illegal activities to truly criminal structures like prison gangs.
We have an obligation to recognize gambling as an economic activity and that there is a 'social fact' that must be addressed. Only the legalization of market demand will allow the State to control, collect taxes on, and regulate this activity in the country.
Despite the scars, the long years spent defending the legalization of gambling in Brazil place us in the position of privileged spectators. We have seen major media groups modify their editorial lines, conservative politicians change their minds, a bill passed in the Chamber of Deputies during a conservative government, and the Workers' Party revise its views on the obvious.
I couldn't end this text without mentioning a concept that first emerged in 2005, has come of age, and is beginning to be understood by the Executive, Legislative, media, and society.
"The government and society should think carefully before transforming the good intentions of honorable citizens into new business opportunities for organized crime. Those who want to gamble, but cannot do so legally, will seek it on the black market. There will always be an entrepreneur, like Al Capone, to give society what society desires."


