Roberto DaMatta: The Ironies of Fate

Opinion I 02.10.19

By: Elaine Silva

Share:
Roberto DaMatta

On one of the most successful talk shows on American television, its star host Johnny Carson conducted a memorable interview with Frank Sinatra in 1973. After welcoming the singer, Carson asked if Sinatra listened to himself when he wanted to create a romantic atmosphere with a girlfriend. The question embarrassed Sinatra, as it probably would have embarrassed any great creator, even the most narcissistic.

Did Freud's sexuality harmonize with his theories? Did Mozart, Schubert, and Tchaikovsky listen to each other with as much enthusiasm as we do? Did Shakespeare enjoy his own plays, did Hemingway reread The Old Man and the Sea with admiration? And did Machado de Assis smile, contemplating himself, when he returned to his most radical ironies, those that undoubtedly reflected his identity?
*
When I lose sleep and my fantasy transforms me into a lottery winner, making the ideal coincide with reality, I sleep the sleep of the just. But what if I were to win? The possibility produces a certain agony… Getting rich through a “stroke of luck” brings happiness or misfortune, as we have witnessed. Success – triumph – is literally an escape. But where can the door open to? Money gained suddenly is associated more with the Devil than with God. The Brazilian malaise shows what happens in a system marked by legalized privileges alongside an absurd combination of liberalism and familism. A similar crisis occurs with the radical narcissist – or with those who control their prisoner so much that they stay in the cell with them, imprisoning themselves. The insolvency of a system that changes in order not to change has the same structure as a singer who only admires their own song.
*
In the immense sea of ​​ironies that plagues the world and Brazil, an astonishing prize of R$ 120 million went to advisors to the president of the PT party through a coherently collective game (a lottery pool). The tone of the news was paradoxical: how do defenders of the poor become rich? The vision of the rich in every era and place is permeated by envy and resentment.
The PT is the party of the workers. Of those punished and oppressed by work, which may be an exaggeration, but it has its reason in a system rooted in slavery, responsible for the Brazilian ideal of not working, but of "getting by" through a public job with a guaranteed and hereditary pension. A "gravy train" whose main obligation is the noble art of scratching one's balls.
It's an irony of the gods to see PT (Workers' Party) members receive so much money, but not enough for total change. First, because the prize was won by 46 people, reducing hundreds of millions to a "measly" 2,5 million for each lucky "poor" person. Some complained about being left out of the pool; others mentioned that 2 million is little for employees whose salaries range from R$ 3,6 to R$ 20. There was also the wise word from the party leadership, exempting the winners from the party tithe.
*
Like an uninvited guest, chance produced "rich" people in a party devoted to the "poor." Did Sinatra listen to his records to create a romantic atmosphere? Would you and I do philanthropy or charity if we became rich?
The theory is easy. The complicated part is when there's an unexpected encounter between the ideal and the real. In this case, as Raymond Aron said, what's needed is "active pessimism": having faith without illusion in the face of unforeseen events. Especially in a country so prone to building only to undo, like Brazil…The State of S. Paul (SP)

Share: