Around the world: casinos and gambling

The exploitation of gambling, betting, and casinos has historically generated heated discussions not only in Brazil but throughout the world. This fact, coupled with cultural diversity and different legislative traditions, has contributed to the emergence of various regulatory models, each with its own peculiarities.
In this article, we will present the main points of some of the most relevant regulatory models for gambling, betting, and casinos, with the aim of establishing parameters for the analysis of a Brazilian regulatory model.
Perhaps the most emblematic of the international references in the gambling and casino market in the world is the United States, with Las Vegas as the prime example of an industry that has an estimated economic impact of approximately R$ 1,3 trillion (US$ 261 billion), involving the direct or indirect creation of 1,8 million jobs across the country [1] . In the American model, the operation of gambling and casinos is permitted according to federal law, with states responsible for imposing restrictions and prohibitions. At the state level, in turn, there are various operating models, ranging from more open to more restricted models.
Some states, such as Nevada and Louisiana, allow casinos throughout their territory, imposing zoning and licensing restrictions, while other states limit casino operation to only certain cities or districts, as is the case in Atlantic City, New Jersey, and Tunica, Mississippi. Still other states restrict the practice almost completely, allowing it only for charitable or lottery purposes, such as South Carolina.
In the case of Nevada, the state responsible for regulations applicable to Las Vegas, casino operations are authorized, and anti-money laundering policies are outlined in federal regulations, including the development of internal controls, independent audit and compliance procedures, as well as systems for verifying and recording customer information.
The situation is different with regard to electronic betting, given that few American states legalize and license electronic casinos. Even among the states that allow it, the provision of the service is limited to residents and those located within the state where it is legalized, a reason that generally ends up restricting the operation of online platforms, making them less competitive compared to foreign platforms.
Looking at Europe, the tradition of gambling is prominent in several countries, with the United Kingdom being a clear example of transformation after a restructuring process, which took place through the Gambling Act 2005. This allowed for a considerable opening in the gambling market, and was reformed in 2014 and 2020 to adapt to the digital age.
In general, the United Kingdom openly permits gambling operations both physically and digitally, with specific licenses required for operating such activities. An operating license is required for any establishment offering gambling-related services, whether offered remotely or not. Furthermore, specific licenses are required for physical premises intended for gambling activities (in the case of casinos or bingo halls, for example), as well as personal licenses for individuals performing management and operational functions in gambling establishments.
British regulations are considered a benchmark, given that they are one of the most comprehensive frameworks regarding policies for the protection of minors and vulnerable individuals, as well as protection against money laundering. Regarding the second point, it is important to highlight the requirement for a risk assessment regarding the possibility of the business being used for money laundering and terrorist financing, the development of preventive control policies, monitoring and review of control policies to ensure their effectiveness, as well as their updating based on new guidelines presented by the Gambling Commission, the body responsible for regulation and oversight in the United Kingdom.
Still in Europe, another country whose regulations serve as a benchmark for development in other countries is France. Being a country with a very strong Catholic tradition, gambling was prohibited for much of French history. Over time, however, exceptions were created for some types of games, until, in 2019, the Action Plan for the Growth and Transformation of Enterprises allowed the French government to reform the regulations on betting and gambling.
The regulatory reform came in October of the same year, bringing several changes, especially in the regulatory vision, which moves away from a restrictive focus and aims to guarantee integrity and transparency in betting operations, prevent excessive betting, protect minors, prevent fraudulent activities and money laundering, and promote the balanced use of different forms of gambling.
Currently, France issues licenses to physical establishments that offer betting on horse and dog racing, casino games, poker, card game clubs, billiards, among others. Sports betting and lotteries are also offered in the country, but are included within the monopoly of a recently privatized company, La Française des Jeux.
Regarding online betting, all platforms targeting the French public must be licensed by the National Gaming Authority (ANJ). Additionally, all platform providers must be listed in the licensing application. Furthermore, the software used by the platforms must be submitted to the ANJ for certification.
Currently permitted activities include poker, sports betting, and horse racing betting. The regulations do not restrict licenses to companies based in France only; they also allow companies located in the European Union or the European Economic Area, provided they have a treaty on tax evasion and fraud with France.
Regarding anti-money laundering controls, the regulations are similar to the British model, requiring customer identification and the implementation of internal audit and control procedures to prevent money laundering.
Moving on to the Asian continent, an important reference point regarding the gambling market is Singapore. The country's regulation is not formalized through a consolidated statute, but rather through a set of rules governing the activities of betting houses (Betting Act), public gaming houses and lotteries (Common Gaming Houses Act), private lotteries (Private Lotteries Act), and licensed casinos (Casino Control Act). Furthermore, online platforms are regulated by the Remote Gambling Act. Similar to the United Kingdom, Singaporean casinos are required to conduct regular internal due diligence to detect potential loopholes for money laundering and terrorist financing.
Regarding online gambling, the Remote Gambling Act establishes a different system, in which all online activities are prohibited, except for those that have received an exemption. The process to obtain an exemption requires that the operations center be located in Singapore, as well as that all relevant online content also be hosted domestically.
Furthermore, a number of restrictions may be applied depending on the authority's judgment regarding the measures necessary to prevent harm related to addiction and money laundering. In 2016, the Singaporean government approved exemptions for the Singapore Turf Club and Singapore Pools, with the restriction that electronic activities should be limited to products already existing in the establishments, restricting casino-style gambling.
These are the main models that inspire discussions and modeling in Brazil, especially the current text of Senate Bill 186/2014 and Bill 442/1991 , the latter recently approved in the Chamber of Deputies and now awaiting consideration by the senators. In the next article, we will discuss the main bills under consideration in the country and the prospects for the legalization of gambling and casinos.
***
[1] See data from the American Gaming Association, the main association of casino industry companies in the USA. https://www.americangaming.org/
***
Mariana Saragoça – Lawyer. Partner at the Stocche Forbes law firm, which operates in the areas of Administrative Law, Infrastructure and Regulation, with emphasis on bidding processes (especially public-private partnerships – PPPs and concessions), administrative contracts and regulation of the main infrastructure sectors in Brazil. Bachelor of Laws from the Faculty of Law of the University of São Paulo (USP). Postgraduate degree in Infrastructure Law from the São Paulo Law School of the Getúlio Vargas Foundation (GVLaw). Gregory Barbosa Barbosa – Lawyer on the Administrative Law and Regulated Sectors team at Stocche Forbes Advogados. Bachelor of Laws from the Dom Hélder Câmara Higher School (ESDHC). Victor Nogueira – Legal Assistant on the Administrative Law and Regulated Sectors team at Stocche Forbes Advogados. Law student at the Faculty of Law of the University of São Paulo (FD-USP). The article above was published on Jota.Info.


