Bets: when a high balance becomes suspicious

The ban on betting sites, determined by Provisional Measure No. 1.394/2026, brought a consequence that goes beyond the closure of activities, since, in the return of balances, the government identified dozens of bettors' accounts with more than R$ 500 and announced their analysis for possible money laundering.
In this context, it is indeed true that high values may attract the attention of regulatory bodies, especially in a sector vulnerable to the circulation of illicit funds. However, the size of a balance should not, in itself, clarify its origin or demonstrate concealment or dissimulation of assets.
It is also evident that the funds were on platforms previously authorized by the State, so examining the transactions under the lens of the subsequent prohibition creates the risk of making illegal what was previously permitted.
Given this, it is not coherent to allow this reversal, since the prohibition of an economic activity does not, in itself, modify the legal nature of previously carried out operations, nor does it transform the money that remained deposited on the platform into the proceeds of crime.
This does not mean, however, preventing investigations when there are concrete circumstances of irregularity, since transactions incompatible with income, transfers from third parties, or acts of concealment may justify investigative measures aimed at clarifying possible illicit conduct, provided they are assessed in their context and not presumed from the balance.
Therefore, it is necessary to distinguish between statistical anomaly and criminal suspicion. The former may justify preliminary checks, while the latter requires objective elements that indicate a minimally substantiated criminal hypothesis.
At this point, criminal investigation cannot be treated as a mere investigative procedure at the disposal of the State, especially since its initiation can represent a significant intervention in fundamental rights, paving the way for access to protected information, obtaining financial intelligence reports, and adopting invasive measures regarding the privacy and assets of the individual.
From this perspective, the possibility of the assets in question becoming unavailable deserves attention, considering that CMN Resolution No. 5.320/2026 provides for the administrative blocking of accounts linked to the irregular operation of betting.
Although the measure is originally aimed at unauthorized operators, its application could, depending on the interpretation given to the scope of the rule, indirectly affect assets belonging to bettors that are still in the custody of these companies, creating the risk that a measure intended to stop irregular activity may produce restrictive effects on the assets of third parties, especially in light of the subsequent prohibition of gambling in the country.
Therefore, any investigative hypotheses formulated unilaterally by the authority must be supported by concrete and verifiable elements, otherwise the very logic of fundamental guarantees would be reversed, allowing someone to be investigated not because there are objective reasons to suspect the commission of a crime, but so that the State can subsequently seek elements capable of justifying the suspicion that gave rise to the investigation.
That being said, it is important to recognize that money laundering prevention must target structures that use the betting market to conceal assets of criminal origin. However, its effectiveness cannot be measured by the willingness to investigate every unusual financial transaction, but by the ability to identify concrete circumstances that effectively indicate the commission of illegal acts.
Ultimately, the difference between legitimate money and assets of criminal origin lies not in the size of the balance, but in the circumstances that explain its formation, since it is the existence of founded suspicion that should justify the investigation, and not the investigation that should serve the subsequent search for elements capable of substantiating the suspicion that gave rise to it.
(*) Leonardo Tajaribe Jr. is a criminal defense attorney with a postgraduate degree in Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure from Cândido Mendes University (UCAM) and specialized in Economic Criminal Law from the University of Coimbra/IBCCRIM.


