LOTTOPAR documentary shows why video lottery is not a slot machine.

To an outsider, all gaming machines look the same. The lights, the reels, the colors, and the animations are repeated in a Las Vegas casino, a regulated lottery terminal, and a clandestine machine hidden in the back of a bar. Clearing up this confusion is the goal of the documentary produced by the Paraná State Lottery (Lottopar), which will be released this weekend with exclusive distribution by BNLData.
The film compares the video lottery terminal (VLT) with slot machines. To do this, it interviewed Brazilians and Americans. Representing Lottopar are the president, Daniel Romanowski, and collaborator Rodrigo Morosini. Representing the supplier AGS are the CEO and president, David Lopez, Marcus Fortunato (vice-president for Brazil), Drew Pawlack (vice-president for Latin America), and developer Bruno Fortunato. Also participating are executives from the GLI and BMM laboratories, the top brass of the Paraná Scientific Police, the president of the Nevada Gaming Control Board, Mike Dreitzer, and businesspeople from Maryland and Minnesota in the United States, where this type of game has been operated for decades. In Brazil, the VLT is a form of instant lottery operated by state lotteries within the law. Slot machines remain prohibited and classified as gambling.
"In the end, the difference was never just in the machines. It was always in the choices," the narration says at the end. "Paraná made its choice."
Electronic scratch card, not a casino.
The central point of the documentary is the GLI 14 technical standard, adopted in the United States video lottery markets. According to Drew Pawlack, it is present in 27 US states. AGS has been operating in this market for over three decades, in states such as Maryland, Ohio, and Indiana, and is now expanding to North Dakota. Under Brazilian law, a GLI 14 game is an instant lottery, that is, an electronic scratch-off ticket.
The logic is the same as with a physical ticket. The lottery prints a closed batch of tickets, all with the result already defined, and knows in advance how much it will collect and how much it will pay in prizes. In the VLT (Light Rail Transit), the batch is a numbered series stored on a central server. “Once placed on the central server, the entire series will be played before a new one begins. There is no possibility of a prize announced to the consumer not being won,” explains Pawlack.
Casino slot machines follow a different rule, GLI 11. In these machines, each play is an independent draw made by a random number generator (RNG): the result does not deviate from the set of possibilities, and the odds are always the same. In electronic scratch cards, on the other hand, the number of prizes in each series is fixed, and all will be paid out by the end of the series.
Mackenzie Haugh, Director of Operations at GLI, explains that a certified GLI 14 machine has undergone a rigorous testing process. Non-certified machines, on the other hand, "may not meet a minimum standard and may, in fact, not be fair to the player."
Marcus Fortunato summarizes: “Many times we get caught up in the figures, the images, the colors, the lights of the game. But, in reality, the player is playing mathematics.” What makes a game a lottery, according to him, is what's behind the screen: a central server that distributes serially numbered results, approved by the lottery, regulated by the State, and certified by an independent laboratory.
"It may look like a duck, but it's not a duck."
Mary Lanham, owner of Rod N' Reel in Maryland, recounts how her father, Gerald Donovan, defended the practice before the Supreme Court. Someone in the court said that if something walks like a duck and looks like a duck, it is a duck. “And he said, ‘No, it isn’t.’ Someone brought the machine to court and he explained why it might look like a duck, it might walk like a duck, but it isn’t a duck.”
Rod N' Reel is a family business founded in 1946 with a marina and a restaurant. It acquired a bingo hall in 1979 and video lottery (VLT) machines in 1995. Mary Lanham highlights the relationship with the Maryland Lottery Commission, which conducts periodic audits and inspections and maintains a Voluntary Exclusion Program. The fee charged on the operation, she says, was passed on to the state for schools and streets. “This offered us protection, longevity. It created a solid foundation for our business.”
Nathan Benefiel, manager of Bingo World, also in Maryland, recalls the prejudice he faced when telling his college classmates where he worked. “People would say, ‘Is this legal?’ Having the State Commission’s oversight removed any possibility of a gray market and placed us in a solid business environment.”
Gary Luckett, owner of Traders, is blunt: “I don’t believe I would be open if it weren’t for the video lottery (VLTs). That helped us survive for 25 years.”
The demonstration of the three containers.
One of the most instructive parts of the film is the demonstration conducted by Marcus Fortunato. He uses three containers, each with ten balls: seven white (prize zero), two pink (prize two), and one blue (prize five). With this setup, the machine returns 90% to the player (the so-called RTP, return to player) and awards prizes in 30% of the plays.
In a casino slot machine, the drawn ball returns to the receptacle and the odds never change. In video lottery (VLT), the drawn ball is eliminated. The total return to the player remains the same, but the chance of winning the top prize increases with each play: it goes from one in ten to one in nine, then one in eight, until the end of the series. “In a finite draw game, I know I'll have X number of winners for Y number of balls. In a casino slot machine, I could have a sequence of only winners or only losers,” Fortunato summarizes.
On the illegal machine, the operator advertises an RTP of 90%, a frequency of 30%, and a maximum prize of five. Then he removes the blue ball and replaces it with a white one. To maintain the illusion that the machine pays, he also swaps one of the balls with a value of two. "The maximum prize only exists in the advertising. It doesn't exist on the machine, and there's no way to win," says Marcus Fortunato.
For the Brazilian player, the guidance is simple. The casino machine is called a "unicorn" in the film because Brazilian law does not allow it. That leaves video lottery and the illegal machine, and to differentiate them, no technical knowledge is needed: just look for equipment approved by Lottopar. "All the announced results will come true, from zero prizes to the biggest ones. It's guaranteed and it's part of the law."
Laboratory opens source code
The documentary also shows how the certification process works. Travis Foley, executive director of the BMM lab, explains that technicians play the machines to check if the results pay what they promise. In addition, they analyze the source code to verify the mathematical model, the payouts, and the probabilities. "We ensure that there are no secondary decisions that could deviate from the predicted mathematical formula. There is no possibility that, if there is a value to be paid, the machine will decide not to pay," he states.
Scientific Police: slot machines programmed not to pay out.
The film addresses the fight against illegal gambling as a matter of public safety. “We are not talking about a mere misdemeanor, about a fun illegal game. We are talking about a billion-dollar organization whose foundation is raising money through illegal gambling,” states Luiz Rodrigo Grochocki, Chief Inspector of the Scientific Police of Paraná. According to him, the money taken from gamblers can finance other fronts of organized crime, such as the purchase of weapons, drug trafficking, and money laundering. He also warns business owners: “You are bringing a criminal organization into your establishment.”
Expert Luiz Quadros, from the same institution, explains that the seized machines undergo reverse engineering of their software, and most of these programs have the option to be configured to not pay any prize, "only to collect money." He points out three differences between a certified slot machine and a certified video lottery:
⇒ Manufacturing: slot machines are manufactured clandestinely. Video lottery games come from certified manufacturers and are laboratory tested.
⇒ Return to Player (RTP): In slot machines, the operator sets the RTP as they wish. In video lottery, the percentage is fixed by law and regulation.
⇒ Auditing: in slot machines, it doesn't exist. In video lottery games, all records are inviolable and accessible to regulatory bodies.
Nevada: "The real cost is the loss of trust."
Mike Dreitzer chairs the Nevada Gaming Control Board, one of the most influential gaming regulators in the world. He explains that in Nevada, gambling is a "licensing privilege industry": no one is entitled to a license, and all applicants undergo a thorough background check. "The non-negotiables are: that they be people of integrity, with business acumen, and that there is nothing in their past that brings concern, disrepute, or shame to the state of Nevada."
According to Dreitzer, "you can't regulate halfway." "You have to create an appropriate structure. Where that doesn't exist, you end up causing all sorts of social harm to the people who are victimized, who lose their money unfairly, who are victims of fraud." And he compares: "If you want to operate a lemonade stand, there won't be any friction. But if you want to be in the gaming industry, you have to follow the rules."
Regarding illegal gambling, he states that "the real cost is the loss of trust." Nevada has about 3 licensed gambling operators, "from the largest casino to the smallest tavern or liquor store that has slot machines," and the Board has just celebrated its 70th anniversary. "Every time a player presses that button to gamble, there's trust. And there are 70 years behind that." Dreitzer also mentions the state law that mandates the return of profits obtained from illegal gambling: "You have to put them in your wallet." And he concludes: "Illegal gambling and illegal machines corrode our system, and we have to continue fighting against it."
Minnesota: NFL stadium paid for ahead of schedule.
In Minnesota, the film recounts how electronic scratch-off games on tablets, adopted in 2012, became a source of funding for the Minnesota Vikings' NFL stadium. "The bonds issued by the state to pay for the stadium were paid off 20 years ahead of schedule, in 2022, after only ten years," says John Weaver, president and CEO of Pilot Games. For him, player confidence doesn't come from the certification seal: "If you say 'GLI certified' to a player, that means nothing to them. Confidence comes from playing, from the experience, and from knowing that the government is behind the games."
Keith Franke is both mayor and bar owner with the vending machines. He says the economic impact on his business has been "ten times greater" and that the revenue going to charities eases the municipality's tax burden. "As mayor, I'm even happier than as a business owner."
PIX and the "last great frontier"
The Brazilian payment model is attracting the attention of foreign interviewees. Drew Pawlack compares Paraná's cashless system, based on PIX, with the card model that AGS operates in Mexico, with around 7 games. "Seeing how fast and transparent the transaction is for everyone, from the Central Bank to the operator, with all players identified, is literally being light-years ahead of anything done in the rest of the world."
He also praises the operation in Paraná: “Brazil is an emerging market, still evolving. But in Paraná, Lottopar licensed an operator with a level of professionalism that often surpasses the American market. Paraná is an atypical case.”
David Lopez, CEO and president of AGS, explains why the company is investing in the country. “If we want to enter a market, the first thing is that it needs to be regulated. There has to be transparency, there has to be some kind of government oversight,” he states. For him, the potential is unique: “Brazil is the last great frontier of the gaming market. There is no other part of the world with this importance, this size of population, and this appetite for entertainment.”
Lottopar at the forefront
Created in 2022, Lottopar regulates, oversees, and operates the lottery service in Paraná, encompassing fixed-odds, instant, prognostic, and passive betting modalities. “Our mission is to regulate, oversee, and operate the lottery service in the state of Paraná, guaranteeing a safe and fraud-free market,” states Daniel Romanowski, president of the agency. According to him, Lottopar works with accredited international laboratories, such as GLI, and is associated with the World Lottery Association (WLA) and the Ibero-American Corporation of State Lotteries and Betting (CIBELAE), whose board of directors it is a member of. “These associations ensure that Lottopar is aligned with best practices for safe gaming and money laundering prevention,” he says. Part of the revenue goes to public safety, affordable housing, and social programs. Lottopar also maintains a responsible gaming program, with awareness campaigns to prevent abuse, protect minors, and combat illegality.


