End of agreement between CEF and Loteria Mineira frustrates lottery outlets.
Unilateral, petty, and arbitrary. That's how Representative Délio Malheiros (PV) described the decision by Caixa Econômica Federal (CEF) not to extend the agreement that allowed lottery outlets to sell tickets for the Minas Gerais Lottery. At the public hearing of the Consumer and Taxpayer Defense Committee of the Minas Gerais Legislative Assembly held this Wednesday (May 2, 2010), the representative, who requested the meeting, stated that he intends to mobilize other parliamentarians, the Brazilian Bar Association, and the State Government itself to reverse the decision.
The agreement between Caixa Econômica Federal (CEF) and the Minas Gerais Lottery expired on the 31st of last month, and the bank announced that it would not be renewed. To ensure a "smoother transition," as defined by Caixa's lawyer, Helena Silveira, the sale of Minas Gerais Lottery products was permitted until the end of June. However, this did not satisfy lottery shop owners: they want a one-year extension. According to the president of the Minas Gerais Lottery Shop Owners Union (Sicoemg), Marcelo Gomes de Araújo, the end of the agreement will represent an estimated loss of 8% to 12% in the establishments' revenue. In requesting that CEF reconsider its decision, he argued that this represents a significant loss for the shops, despite being insignificant for Caixa.
The bank's lawyer, Helena Silveira, argued that the institution honored the contract and stated that its termination complies with a court order and is therefore based on the law. For the lottery operators' lawyer, Marco Vinício Martins de Sá, the binding precedent issued by the Supreme Federal Court (STF) prohibits the State from legislating on lotteries, but does not prevent it from maintaining them. Meanwhile, the regional superintendent of CEF (Caixa Econômica Federal), Júlio César Reis, reported that the bank is studying alternatives to avoid the decapitalization of the lottery outlets.
Worry
Speaking on behalf of other lottery shop owners, businessman Marcelo Pacífico complained about progressive income losses over the past ten years and said that the economic situation of these establishments is becoming unbearable. After predicting a series of bankruptcies of the shops, he stated that he is diversifying his professional activity, as he does not believe that CEF (Caixa Econômica Federal) will provide any compensation to the lottery shops.
The Director-General of the Minas Gerais Lottery, Ernane Campos Porto, spoke about the institution's social achievements, such as its participation in the construction of the Mineirão stadium and the Hilton Rocha Institute. Délio Malheiros added that the end of the agreement signals "the closure of a century-old institution that provides a very important service to Minas Gerais." He also reminded that numerous charitable institutions that survive on resources from the Minas Gerais Lottery are also at risk of closing their doors.
The number of robberies at lottery outlets has decreased.
The issue of security in lottery establishments was another topic on the agenda of the public hearing. Representatives from the Civil and Military Police presented statistics at the meeting that demonstrate a reduction in the number of robberies. According to Major Alfredo José Alves Veloso, in the first four months of 2010 there were two incidents, while in the same period last year there were eight, and in 2008, ten. This is due, according to him, to preventive and repressive actions by the police, as well as increased caution on the part of the stores.
Delegate Horivelton Cabral Ribeiro suggested that lottery outlets adopt self-protection procedures, such as hiring security guards, installing closed-circuit television, revolving doors with metal detectors, and devices for scanning customers' identity documents at the entrance.
In response to a question from Representative Délio Malheiros regarding CEF's project to offer the possibility of placing bets via the internet, the bank's regional superintendent, Júlio César Reis, stated that this is still under study, but that the objective is to broaden the customer base of the lottery outlets themselves, since it will allow bettors to choose the store through which they wish to place their bets.
At the end of the meeting, Deputy Alencar da Silveira Jr. (PDT) criticized what he called CEF's lack of commitment to Minas Gerais and cast doubt on the lotteries held by the institution. Regarding the end of the agreement with the Minas Gerais Lottery, he said that the problem could have been avoided if, ten years ago, it had created its own network of stores. Representatives of the lottery outlets also complained about the suspension of the assistance for transporting valuables offered by CEF to stores penalized for committing some irregularity.
Attendances
Representatives Adalclever Lopes (PMDB), president; Délio Malheiros (PV), Alencar da Silveira Jr. (PDT), and Carlin Moura (PCdoB). (Ascom ALMG)


