The government that needed BNLData to understand its own numbers.

Bets I 18.11.26

By: Magno José

Share:
The government that needed BNLData to understand its own numbers.
Without access to the Treasury's data, the Ministry of Health cited BNLData in a technical note that the Attorney General's Office (AGU) submitted to the Supreme Federal Court (STF) to defend the Provisional Measure on Betting. The ministry itself admits that cooperation with the Secretariat of Prizes and Betting "has not yet materialized."

There are documents that reveal more by what they unintentionally disclose than by what they intend to prove. This is the case with Technical Note No. 60/2026 ( Technical Note No. 60/2026 Ministry of Health ), from the Department of Mental Health, Alcohol and Other Drugs of the Ministry of Health, one of the four annexes that the Attorney General's Office attached to ADIs 8024, 8027, 8028 and 8035, in the Supreme Federal Court, to support Provisional Measure No. 1.394/2026.

When discussing the economic impact of betting, the note states that the sector's revenue (GGR) totaled R$ 20,07 billion in the first half of 2026, with 30,9 million registered CPF numbers (Brazilian individual taxpayer registration numbers). The source indicated is not the Ministry of Finance, nor the Secretariat of Prizes and Betting (SPA), nor the Betting Management System (SIGAP). The source is BNLData.

The numbers are correct. They were obtained by this website through the Access to Information Law, precisely because the government was not disclosing them. The problem is not the data itself. It lies in the fact that one ministry had to resort to a specialized media outlet to find out what another ministry within the same government had hidden away.

The confession is in the court order.

This is not speculation. The dispatch from the same department, signed on October 1, 2026, states that access to SIGAP data is "a fundamental condition for better understanding the Brazilian scenario." It adds that, although the sharing is foreseen in Technical Cooperation Agreement No. 39/2025, signed between SPA and the Secretariat of Specialized Health Care, it "has not yet been implemented."

The same report acknowledges that "much of the data is still being collected, making it impossible to accurately predict the full extent of the impacts."

In other words, the ministry that spoke most in favor of the ban, whose minister presented the Supreme Court with the figure of a suicide risk "15 times higher," did not have access to the market data it proposed to prohibit.

Studies that don't communicate with each other.

In the petition, the Attorney General's Office (AGU) states that the Provisional Measure resulted from a process of "vigilant monitoring and follow-up of public policy," during which federal agencies "produced information, studies, and evaluations." The phrase is in bold.

The annexes tell a different story. The Health Ministry's note was signed on September 9th to update supporting documents for ADI 7749, a request made to the ministry in November 2024. It is not a study on the prohibition and does not recommend the prohibition. The notes from SPA (October 29th) and the National Secretariat for Digital Rights (November 10th) were produced after the Provisional Measure, to provide information for the public hearing and the Union's defense.

And even the numbers don't match. The SPA's report sent to the AGU states a GGR of R$ 20,22 billion in the same semester in which the Ministry of Health, citing BNLData, reports R$ 20,07 billion. These are two figures from the same government, for the same period, in the same process. If the official data was revised, even the Ministry of Health didn't know.

Monitoring of what?

A government that closely monitors a public policy does not leave an agreement that would allow the Health Ministry to access sector data ineffective for almost a year. Nor does it impose secrecy on the preparatory documents for the measure, as revealed by Estadão, nor does it respond to the Access to Information Laws (LAIs) with the information that there are no impact studies.

What the attachments show is a government that decided first and then sought justifications later. In some of these cases, it had to knock on the door of BNLData.

Let it be noted: if quality information about the regulated market reached the Ministry of Health's technical report, it was because the specialized press did the work that official transparency failed to do.


Petition from the Attorney General's Office

Information Note SEI No. 3005/2026/MF – SPA

Presentation by the Ministry of Health at the Public Hearing

Technical Note No. 60/2026 Ministry of Health

Information No. 39/2026 – Ministry of Justice and Public Security

The Attorney General's Office's attachments to the Supreme Court contradict the very defense of the Provisional Measure on Bets.

 


Share: