Regulating gambling means revenue, jobs, and a growing economy.

Regulating gambling means revenue, jobs, and a growing economy.
How about we put aside our prejudices and have a serious conversation about the proposed Legal Framework for Games in Brazil?

When it comes to games and bets or games of chance, we think of our favorite team, a number or numerical combination formed by the day, month, and year of our mother's, father's, or brother's birthday, and so on. Examples abound, each with its own particular belief.
If you've never gambled or bet, you probably know at least one person who has tried this market or someone who has won a prize in a game or bet. In Brazil, this industry has been around for a long time. Today, the illegal gambling and betting market moves figures exceeding R$ 20 billion reais/year. Our country doesn't see a penny of that money.
Illegal market? Yes! Apart from bets placed through Caixa Econômica operations, for about 80 years Brazil has treated bingo, casinos, jogo do bicho (a type of lottery), slot machines and similar games as illegal activities. The market has operated clandestinely for eight decades. During this time it has grown, employed people and continues to guarantee their daily bread.
It has also kept pace with technological advancements and even offers options that fit in the palm of your hand, through cell phones and the internet. In Europe and Asia, gambling is a form of entertainment – official, regulated, and taxed – that attracts thousands of people and employs thousands more, directly and indirectly, including waiters, cooks, taxi drivers…
Promoting tourism is an undeniable advantage. So undeniable that, recently, the United Arab Emirates, a country that attracts thousands of foreigners, announced a partnership with a casino giant, Wynn Resorts, based in Las Vegas (USA). The Islamic religion prohibits this type of activity, but the agreement already signals that things are changing in the Middle East.
In the Americas, this market operates legally – with the exception of Cuba and Brazil, which "exports" 200 citizens a year who leave to gamble and bet. In other words, they boost the economies of other nations. In the United States, for example, this industry generates almost 2 million jobs in more than 200 types of professions that receive US$74 billion annually. Legalized, the market in Brazil would generate more than R$60 billion per year and pay approximately R$20 billion in taxes.
Who benefits from the perpetuation of this thriving market without regulation here? It's not about legalizing an industry that is currently illegal, but rather about encouraging the creation of a new one, or at least the safe and fair expansion of an existing one. Why continue to uphold fallacious arguments that gambling fuels businesses of dubious origin and shady activity?
We want to fill these gaps through the law. It is indeed possible, with the right measures – including the non-use of cash – to combat terrorism and money laundering associated with gambling and betting. Regulating the market will not cause more (or fewer) people to become addicted to gambling and betting, because we have already presented alternatives to identify these player profiles and act directly on the issue of addiction.
Who are the "addicts" among the 20 million Brazilians who bet daily on the jogo do bicho, one of the oldest illegal gambling games in the country? Well, it's impossible to know. The jogo do bicho alone involves around 450 jobs. If we consider other forms of gambling, formalizing the industry could provide around 650 direct jobs and 200 new positions.
How about we put aside prejudices, judgments, and assumptions and talk seriously about the proposed Legal Framework for Gambling in Brazil? First, the understanding is that gambling and betting is considered a typically private economic activity subject to state control. Therefore, it is not a public service. Access to this market will not be free, but conditional upon obtaining consent. Authorizations, licenses, and rules within this chain must be respected, from operators and operating locations to players. It will be necessary to act within the law. This applies to everyone.
Acting within the law means revenue collection, taxation, generation of direct and indirect formal jobs, income, a thriving economy, and development. Why not legalize and treat with care gambling and betting, the establishments and/or environments where they operate, those responsible for them, as well as the players and bettors who benefit from this industry? In Congress, the bill to regulate the activities of this production chain has been stalled for three decades, barely taking two steps forward, three steps back, and remaining stuck.
For two years, the Covid-19 pandemic has severely and primarily penalized the events and tourism sectors. Brazil needs tools that will help overcome the economic crisis. People are going hungry and are unemployed – 14 million people are out of work. The operation of these activities clandestinely does not bring any real benefit to our country. On the contrary, it reinforces the image, among our population and the foreign community, that we are a nation complacent with illegal activities.
And while this issue remains in the realm of debate here – for decades – the roulette wheels spin, the dice roll, the numbered balls bounce, the cards are dealt… Those who have fun consciously and responsibly and still have a chance to win the coveted prizes are definitely lucky. What a shame for Brazil that this eighty-year-old uncertainty persists. In the country – and around the world – the game goes on.
(*) Felipe Carreras – Federal Deputy (PSB-PE) in his second consecutive term, previously served as Secretary of Tourism and Sports for Pernambuco. The article above was published on Jota.Info.
***
Legalizing gambling will bring increased enforcement costs and a rise in crime.
Alleged increase in tax revenue from regularization is overestimated.

Bill 442/1991, which in its latest version deals with the operation of gambling throughout the national territory and provides other measures, has been pending in the National Congress for over 30 years. There have been numerous attempts to approve it, but reason has always prevailed, leaving the proposal without a decision on its merits for all this time.
In our country, the classification of conduct related to the exploitation of gambling is found in Chapter VII of the Law of Criminal Offenses (LCP). Notably, Article 50 of the LCP punishes the establishment or exploitation of "gambling in a public place or a place accessible to the public, whether or not an entrance fee is charged," which is a criminal offense originating from customary conduct, as stated in the chapter title itself, which in turn became criminally punishable, but has much greater repercussions than the simple behavior of the individual.
It is clear that the prohibition of gambling cannot be dissociated from its moral and religious component, but the prohibition is not solely based on these aspects, considering other effects such as harm to public health, security, and the tax issues involved.
The aforementioned legal configuration was established in the legal system and maintained, until then, by a Decree of 1946 and, in this respect, it is important to emphasize that it was linked to the post-Estado Novo movements of democratization, having broad support in the Congress of the time, both from the opposition and from the government, also counting on the adherence of constituent deputies responsible for drafting the Federal Constitution of 1946.
It is my duty, initially, to address the issues of pathological gambling, also known as ludopathy. In this respect, I consider the proposed regulation dangerous, since pathological gambling is related to the disorders of habits and impulses described by the World Health Organization (WHO) in the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD-10), under code F63.0, as a disease, which it indeed is. Therefore, it is the State's duty to combat it and not promote practices that increase its cases in the country.
Pathological gambling consists of frequent and repeated episodes of gambling that dominate an individual's life to the detriment of social, occupational, material, and family values and commitments. The essential aspect of the disorder is persistent and repeated gambling, the frequency of which increases despite adverse social consequences.
At this point, it is important to differentiate between games with immediate and delayed results. Lottery games, for example, are games where the result is determined after a period of time has elapsed since the bet. This characteristic makes addiction to this type of game extremely rare, compared to games with immediate results, such as casino and slot machine games. In these types, the individual places the bet and immediately wins or loses. It is this frenzy for the result that acts as a psychological component and leads to the individual's addiction.
Psychiatric research has shown that individuals who regularly play slot machines become addicted three to four times faster than those who play cards or bet on sports. While delayed-result games require three and a half years of regular play to addict a person, immediate-result games need only one year.
Other research also shows that 50% to 80% of gambling addicts have attempted suicide, compared to a rate of only 5% in the general population. Among those who successfully attempt suicide, the rate is 13% to 20% among gambling addicts, compared to 0,5% of the world average in the general population.
The percentage of gaming revenue spent by gambling addicts also varies greatly between game types. While lottery games account for about 19%, casinos reach 30%, and slot machines account for more than three times the percentage spent on lotteries, further demonstrating why the claim that all games are the same is false.
Another important factor to analyze is the supposed increase in tax revenue. When not overestimated, it is being misrepresented. Proponents of the proposal claim that gambling will generate R$ 74 billion, representing 1% of GDP, which, with a 30% tax rate, would correspond to R$ 22,2 billion in tax revenue. However, these figures are utter fallacies.
Currently, gambling generates R$27,1 billion (0,36% of GDP), according to the proponents of legalization themselves; that is, with regulation there would be an additional R$47 billion. A basic concept in economics is that of trade-off – a choice corresponds to a non-choice. In other words, this same amount spent on gambling will no longer be spent in another sector of the economy. Therefore, there will be a cannibalization of other economic activities by the gambling industry.
The government currently collects around R$ 20,83 billion in taxes on the R$ 74 billion that would go to gambling. Thus, using data from the proponents of the proposals themselves, we would have R$ 8,1 billion from lotteries, R$ 1 billion from illegal gambling (indirect revenue), and R$ 11,7 billion in taxes on the additional R$ 47 billion that would go to gambling, using a conservative assumption of a 25% tax burden.
In this scenario, the additional revenue would be R$ 1,37 billion. This number is significantly lower than the R$ 22,2 billion announced by its proponents. However, this analysis does not yet consider the best-case scenario. If we have a movement of 0,8% of GDP, as occurs in the United States, the additional revenue would be only R$ 630 million. If it falls below 0,6% of GDP, there would be a decrease of at least R$ 110 million in revenue.
These scenarios, as described, still involve a high tax rate. Any rate below 29% would result in a revenue loss. For example, with a movement of 1% of GDP and a tax rate of 25%, we would have a loss of R$ 2,23 billion compared to current revenue.
Another argument used by proponents of the proposal is the increase in tourism, which would be attracted by the games in Brazil. But when we analyze the numbers, we see that our country is one of the fastest growing in tourism in the world, and it is unlikely that the games will be more attractive here than in other countries; in other words, the players will primarily be Brazilian. For the record, it should be noted that, from 1995 to 2019, the world average increase in tourism was 122%, Portugal had a rate of 81%, South Africa grew by 216%, and Brazil saw an increase of 219%.
What our tourism industry needs is investment in public safety to provide greater security for tourists, investment in infrastructure, whether at airports, hotels, or on our roads, and training and professionalization of the receptive market, including fluency in foreign languages. These are the things that will attract new tourists. Games, not necessarily.
I also understand that the fiscal argument cannot stand in this discussion, since the numbers themselves point in the opposite direction to the proposal. Furthermore, it should be noted that the National Association of Federal Revenue Auditors (ANFIP) also opposes the legalization proposal, demonstrating that there should be no tax benefit.
Another important issue in this analysis is the increase in crime rates associated with gambling, with a clear relationship to at least three types: money laundering and organized crime; crimes of opportunity, given the favorable conditions for criminals to operate in areas where people are crowded together, with cash and distracted (around casinos, for example); and also crimes related to compulsive gamblers.
It is also necessary to highlight the positions of the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office (MPF) and the Federal Police (PF), which made a critical and forceful analysis of the regulation of gambling. These are, therefore, state organizations that assessed regulation as a gateway to crimes such as money laundering, tax evasion, white-collar crime, and systemic corruption.
We must also pay attention to the costs of regulation, whether related to oversight, policing, and increased spending on crime fighting and the judicial system, as well as the social costs, which represent an immeasurable value, but are certainly greater than the supposed benefits presented by its proponents.
For all the reasons stated above, I am totally against the regulation of gambling in Brazil and will fight against all attempts in this direction. It is evidently clear that the increase in revenue will be very low or even non-existent, resulting in losses.
There is a huge social cost linked to the oversight, supervision, and cannibalization of other economic activities, as well as the social losses and problems associated with gambling addiction. All this, without even considering the clear link to increased crime, especially organized crime and money laundering.
Being against the regulation of gambling is obviously a matter of morality and customs, but it is far from being just that; it is rather a reasonable position in light of serious analyses of the variables involved. It is recognizing that this is a proposal that will generate enormous profits for the gambling industry – private profits, therefore – but will socialize immense costs for Brazilian society along with an increase in crime.
(*) Antônio Cézar Correia Freire (Cezinha de Madureira) – Federal Deputy (PSD-SP), current president of the Evangelical Parliamentary Front of the National Congress, pastor, journalist and radio broadcaster. The article above was published on Jota.Info.


