Sincoemg Seminar: 'Dreams, Struggles and Ideals' – Part II

Lottery I 22.11.11

By: sync

Share:

GEPLO presents new features of Caixa Lotteries.

The National Manager of the National Lottery Products and Commercial Promotions Department of Caixa Econômica Federal, Edilson Carrogi Ribeiro Vianna, began his presentation by apologizing for the absence of a representative from the network area, stating that "this area is undergoing restructuring and, as a result, the new national manager cannot be here today."

The executive stated that Caixa's approach has always been one of dialogue to strengthen the partnership, "always listening and negotiating." He also highlighted the importance of lottery operators to the country and noted the diverse demands and expectations they face.

According to Carrogi, the lottery area initially worked with an ambitious goal of 22% revenue growth, but by October this rate had already reached 11% growth compared to the same period last year. Up to October of this year, Caixa Lotteries had already grossed R$ 7,637 million compared to R$ 7,055 million in 2010. 

"But there's also the Mega da Virada lottery, which will greatly improve the results of lottery ticket sales," he commented.

All modalities showed growth compared to the same period last year, except for Dupla Sena (-4,5%). Mega-Sena (3,6%), Lotofácil (17,6%), Lotomania (16,7%), Quina (8,8%), Instant Lottery (2,6%), Federal Lottery (0,8%), Loteca (14,9%), Lotogol (24,7%) and Timemania (38,5%).

Sport betting

Regarding Loteca and Lotogol, Carrogi informed that these products are under analysis and that CEF is also studying sports betting operations, following the global trend of state lotteries. 

“We are working at GEALO to recover these products and are also studying the sports betting operations. We will either remove them from the portfolio or revitalize them,” he commented.

Caixa's proposal is to have a special lottery draw every three months of the year, such as the Easter Lotomania, the São João Quina, the Independence Day Lotofácil, and the New Year's Eve Mega-Sena.

Instant Lottery

Regarding the instant lottery, Carrogi highlighted that despite the product's growth and the success of the new Instant Lottery for Goods and Money, the low payout makes it difficult to increase the prize pool for this product.

"With an average payout of 28% to 32%, this distortion is more noticeable in instant trading," he said.

But he highlighted that the Instant Goods and Money game was important because “today, a credit letter is given to the bettor, and they choose where to buy the item, and can even complete it and acquire an item of greater value. Launched in the first half of May, the 12-month sales expectation for the product was reached in 9 months,” he said. Caixa is studying the launch of instant games with prize 'tablets'.

lotof easy

Initially scheduled for December 5th, the changes to Lotofácil will be implemented on January 16th of next year, with the inclusion of 16 and 17 number games and three weekly draws.

Caixa forwarded the studies for the readjustment of bets on Loteca, Lotogol and Dupla Sena to SEAE, but the Secretariat linked the release of the readjustments to the Certification on Responsible Gaming (scheduled for March 2012) and Lottery Security (scheduled for October 2012) with the World Lottery Association – WLA.

Mega da Virada

Regarding the Mega da Virada lottery, the executive informed that sales will begin on November 28th with a major advertising campaign, headlined by actor Luigi Baricelli.

“Last year we started sales at the beginning of November, but the result was only 4% of sales. The initial prize forecast is R$ 170 million, but we believe it could reach R$ 200 million. In 2010 the prize was R$ 193 million,” he commented.

Federal Pool

Regarding fixed-odds betting or group bets, we are awaiting a statement from SEAE (Special Secretariat for Economic Affairs) regarding pricing, as the operating system is already being tested internally and its implementation on the network should not be a problem.

“This is a project we've cherished since entering the lottery field. It has to be done in a way that's safe for everyone in the system. The value of the shares will always be the same to facilitate the sale of bets. In Mega-Sena, there can be up to 100 shares. We've developed a model that's very easy to understand and work with,” he explained.

Carrogi stated that the most important thing will be to define the service fee, and that this value will be determined by SEAE, with Caixa being responsible for developing the system to include this price in the system.

 

Sincoemg's lawyer explains the difference between 'permission' and 'concession'.

Once again, lawyer Marco Vinício Martins de Sá caused controversy during the seminar by discussing the difference between 'permission' and 'concession' in Caixa's contract with lottery operators. Marco argues that the contracts between Caixa and lottery business owners are concessions of public service, not permissions.

“I’ll be frank and direct with you. I’ve worked in this sector since 1996 and it’s only gotten worse. There hasn’t been any improvement, and I’ll tell you now, it’s going to get even worse, and the blame lies with each and every one of us. The important bill currently under consideration is a problem for all of us, including lottery operators,” he asserted.

The consultant from Sincoemg recalled past disputes with Caixa and cited the example of the lawsuit filed during the technological model change.

“At that time, Sincoemg filed a lawsuit asking to suspend the exchanges. Caixa began to withdraw the incentives that lottery agents had. Then CEF (Caixa Econômica Federal) offered advantages. The lottery agents who resigned based on the promises did not receive the advantages. The union held an assembly and it was decided that the lawsuit would be withdrawn. Afterwards, CEF made the necessary collections,” he recalled.

He then returned to the legal nature of Caixa's contract with lottery operators, asking the following questions: Is it a permit, as the name suggests? Is it a concession? Or is it another type of contract?

According to the lawyer, article 23 of Law 8987/1995 , which outlines the essential clauses of the 'concession' contract, is included in the CEF's 'permit' contract with the lottery operators, with the exception of item IV (regarding the price of the service and the criteria and procedures for adjusting and revising tariffs).

"All the responsibilities foreseen in Chapter VI of the Concession Contract of the aforementioned law are included in the contract, except for the readjustment," he commented.

According to the lawyer, a contract is defined by what is written, but this is not the understanding of Minister José Delgada in Special Appeal 403905, which, according to the rapporteur:

 

"I do not disagree at all with the Appellant when she states that, in truth, the legal fact that resulted in the legal relationship maintained with the Public Administration should, despite the name given to it, be equated to a true concession, from which all pertinent effects arise. Human will, in effect, does not have the power to modify the legal meaning of a fact by merely changing its name , insofar as the legal norm that foresees it, upon its realization, infallibly applies, establishing it: the legal fact results from this, and not from the eventual nomenclature given to it."

 

"The lottery operator has the right to receive fees commensurate with the service provided and that guarantee a return for the concessionaire. Is it legal for a businessman to pay R$ 300 for a lottery outlet to receive payments and then, at the end of 20 years, go home? He should receive the invested capital back at the end of the contract," he ruled.

The lawyer argued that there is no company in the world that has a network of 11 lottery outlets and would play against that network.

"I get sad at these events because every year a friend isn't here because they've stopped being a lottery operator. If I invest the resources to buy a lottery outlet in a 0,8% return investment, it will be more profitable," he said.

Freudian slip

Commenting on the Technical Note issued by Caixa regarding Bill 4280/2008, Marco Vinício cited a slip of the tongue by Caixa. In the last article, which discusses the lottery operator's guarantee of a 10-year contract extension, the document mentions "from the end of the 'concession'"...

EGT - 728 x 90EGT - 1280 x 90 1

Share: