Alfinetei obtains right of reply in court against ICL Notícias for 'fake news'.

The Alfinetei profile, which has over 25 million followers on Instagram, won a legal battle for the right to reply against ICL Notícias, a news portal founded by economist and former banker Eduardo Moreira. The dispute revolves around a video published by ICL claiming that the page was financed by sports betting companies to attack President Lula's government, an accusation that Alfinetei classifies as "fake news" and without any evidence.
In compliance with the court order, ICL Notícias published a retraction video on Instagram with content created by Alfinetei's own legal team. The platform's post explicitly acknowledged the origin of the material: “In compliance with the court decision, we are publishing the right of reply presented by Alfinetei. The content reproduced in the video was created by the plaintiff itself.”
What did the prosecution say?
The original video from ICL Notícias claimed that Alfinetei's publications were part of a political operation organized and financed by a betting organization, aimed at influencing the electoral debate and harming the federal government. The content used expressions such as "massacre of content," "anti-government propaganda," and suggested that reports published by the page could be "fan fiction, lies, inventions, rehearsed text, bought or commissioned."
In its right of reply, Alfinetei refutes each of these points. The company denies having received "any value, benefit or funding from any politician, whether from the right or the left, nor from any political group" and maintains that "political or editorial disagreement with certain content does not authorize labeling it as an irregular piece of propaganda, nor does it transform the regular activity of a digital page into an electoral offense."
ICL News and the pattern of accusations against the sector.
This episode is not an isolated incident in ICL Notícias's history regarding the sports betting market. The portal, founded by Eduardo Moreira, a former partner at Banco Pactual and now an economist with a presence on social media, has already launched a campaign with the hashtag #bettingkills, without providing any basis for the claim. Moreira has also publicly stated that "the betting market is the biggest problem in Brazil."
For Alfinetei, the pattern repeats itself; accusations presented as facts, without concrete evidence. The full text of the right of reply is direct on this point: "The statements made in the video are fake news, lies, and based on conjecture, without any proof."
The point-by-point answer
The statement released by Alfinetei's legal team lists four categorical denials; the company affirms that it has never received payments from politicians of any ideological spectrum; that it does not participate in political operations; that it is not part of disinformation networks; and that it does not produce deliberately false content.
The right of reply also questions ICL's use of the page's reach as an argument for suspicion; "The fact that a page has a significant audience does not make its actions illegal, nor does it turn it into an instrument of political operation." Regarding the lack of immediate response to contacts, the document notes that this "does not equate to a confession or acknowledgment of irregularity."
The text concludes with a final statement: “Criticism is legitimate. False accusations, without proof, are not opinion, but misinformation and should be publicly corrected.”
Obtaining the right of reply through legal means exposes a precise limit; criticism of the betting sector or any company can be freely exercised, but statements presented as factual without evidentiary basis are subject to mandatory correction. For ICL Notícias, whose critical stance towards the betting market is part of its editorial identity, the decision raises a question that remains open: where does positional journalism end and the responsibility for verifying what is published begin?
View this photo on Instagram
***
Check out the text of the right of reply:
"In compliance with the court decision that guaranteed Alfinetei the right to reply, the company clarifies, objectively, that the statements made in the originally published content, which attempted to associate the page's actions with an alleged organized political operation financed by a betting house and aimed at undermining the Federal Government, are false, offensive, without any proof, and constitute fake news."
The video claimed that Alfinetei's publications were anti-government propaganda, part of a content massacre, and an operation aimed at influencing the electoral debate. This narrative is false and untrue. Alfinetei is a brand that produces digital content, publishing materials of public interest, repercussions, reports, statements, and topics circulating on social media, always within the legal limits and guidelines applicable to the platforms in which it operates.
Political or editorial disagreement with certain content does not authorize labeling it as irregular propaganda, nor does it transform the regular activity of a digital page into an electoral offense. The insinuation that Alfinetei participated in an organized political-electoral financing structure is also false and without any proof. The video mentions, without evidence, that there was an organized operation paid for by a betting company, supposedly linked to third parties and intended to harm the Lula government.
Alfinetei rejects this accusation and categorically declares that it has never received any money, benefit, or funding from any politician, whether from the right or the left, nor from any political group.
This is a false and baseless statement. The company does not integrate, coordinate, finance, participate in, or have any connection whatsoever with any political-electoral operation of any kind, nor with any individuals or legal entities mentioned in the video to support this narrative. The attempt to link Alfinetei to political agents, businessmen, investigations, Tigrinho, a sea of mud, or any electoral scheme constitutes a serious, false, and unsubstantiated insinuation, with evident potential to damage the company's honor and reputation.
The video also suggested that Alfinetei's posts could be fan fiction, lies, fabrications, rehearsed text, purchased or commissioned content. These expressions go beyond the right to criticize and present suspicions to the public as if they were facts. There is no evidence that Alfinetei has fabricated accounts, manipulated information, or hired third parties to simulate testimonies. Regarding the allegation of a lack of advertising identification, Alfinetei clarifies that its posts comply with the guidelines of digital platforms and applicable legislation.
It is incorrect to generically and accusingly attribute responsibility to the company for any technical limitations or labeling criteria defined by the digital environment itself. The reference to Alfinetei's number of followers and the reach of its publications was also used in a distorted way. The fact that a page has a significant audience does not make its actions illegal, nor does it turn it into an instrument of political operation.
Similarly, Alfinetei does not control individual user interpretations of the content disseminated. The claim that content helps define elections is mere speculation, without any concrete basis. Alfinetei also notes that the absence of an immediate response to contacts does not equate to confession or acknowledgment of wrongdoing. Therefore, Alfinetei categorically and emphatically denies all accusations, reaffirming that: one, it has never received payments from politicians of any ideological spectrum; two, it does not participate in political operations; three, it is not part of disinformation networks; and four, it does not produce deliberately false content.
The claims made in the video are fake news, lies, and based on conjecture, without any proof. Alfinetei reaffirms its commitment to legality, to the rules of digital platforms, and to the regular exercise of its communication activity. Criticism is legitimate. False accusations, without proof, are not opinion, but misinformation and must be publicly corrected.


