Caixa and Lottery Agents attend Sincoemg seminar.

Lottery I 30.04.08

By: sync

Share:

Representatives from Caixa Econômica Federal, lottery managers and around 230 entrepreneurs participated in the seminar “New Businesses for the Lottery Network”, held this Sunday (27) at the Tauá Hotel & Convention, in the city of Caeté, located in Greater Belo Horizonte. 

In addition to all the presidents of the lottery unions in Brazil, also present at the event were the president of the Minas Gerais Lottery, Fabio Drummond; the superintendent of Lotteries and Games at Caixa Econômica Federal, Roberto Derziê de Sant'Anna; the National Manager of Partner Physical Channels (GEARP), Antônio Carlos Barasuol; the presidents of Febralot, Paulo Leonel Michielon, and Fenal, Aldemar Mascarenhas, as well as guests such as Plínio Machado from Trust Impressores.


Opening

The president of Febralot, Paulo Leonel Michielon , opened the seminar by informing about the resolutions of the Febralot meeting held on Saturday night (26).

"We smoothed out some rough edges and we are united to continue fighting for the category until the end of my term," commented Michielon.

Also at the opening, the president of Fenal, Aldemar Mascarenhas , highlighted the importance of the event for the category and commented on the fact that Timemania was launched before the Mega-Sena price adjustment.

"Caixa launched Timemania, but it didn't take off because there's a price gap between Timemania and Mega-Sena," Mascarenhas stated.

The president of Fenal also reported that there are some partnerships being developed with Caixa, such as the TV Lotérica project, which could guarantee businesses the sale of advertising space on this new media platform. Another project being studied by Caixa is the sale of tickets for concerts and sporting events such as the Brazilian Championship through the Lottery Network.


Panels

In the first panel of the seminar, "Considerations regarding the financial balance of partnership contracts," lawyer Marco Vinício Martins de Sá analyzed the financial balance of partnership contracts between Caixa and lottery operators.

During the presentation, which included strong criticism of Caixa's actions, the lawyer also highlighted the results of the research conducted by the Getúlio Vargas Foundation for Sincoesp.

"Even though lottery business owners are creative, they have problems in this relationship, because in terms of profitability, only what Caixa [the Brazilian lottery operator] deems acceptable is valid," said Marco Vinício, commenting on the fact that online lottery sales and group bets are tolerated by Caixa.

The lawyer also commented that lottery outlets ceased to be a good business after the introduction of financial services, and even stated that the network should only sell "lottery tickets and to offer another service, we have to add value," he commented.

"A person who left a company's voluntary dismissal program and received R$ 200 is crazy to invest in a lottery business. If they invest in the financial market, the return will be higher, and they won't have to work all day, plus they'll avoid the risk of getting a gun pointed at their face," he stated.

Marco Vinício also commented on the reasons why Sincoemg did not withdraw the lawsuit against Caixa, due to losses during the period of migration to the new logistical and technological model of the lottery network.

And he concluded by saying that the lottery network could cease to exist. “What kind of lottery model do you want? This fight isn't about the union, it's about the lottery operators. Think about it and make a decision; if you don't want to cease to exist, do something, and quickly,” Marco Vinício concluded.

The President of the Minas Gerais Lottery, Fabio Drummond , welcomed the lottery agents and presented a film about the Minas Gerais Lottery. In the institutional film, the lottery agents talk about the social projects of the Minas Gerais Lottery, in addition to the project in which part of the resources is allocated to sponsor scholarships for special needs children.

The president of Sincoemg, Marcelo de Gomes Araújo , presented the Panel “Lottery Reengineering”, as reported by BNL last Friday (25).

Marcelo said that it is necessary to find "solutions for our business that generate sustainability, profitability, job creation and human development," he commented.

According to the president of Sincoemg, lottery retailers "sell luck and dreams, but we started selling banking services, putting the games in second place. This generated risks in security, insurance, and labor. Lottery outlets went from a profitable business to one that was difficult to manage and had low profitability," commented Araújo.

During the panel, Marcelo said that the fare increase is a fruitless struggle for the network and that the quality of life worsens every year for business owners. He commented that it would be necessary to find a way out for the business, "because 25% of the network is operating at a loss."

Next, proposals were presented for new solutions for the lottery network, such as ATMs with 24-hour banking services, a promotional channel called 'TV Rede Sorte', a business center, and a research database.

“I made money running lottery games and I’m losing money doing banking services. We have a reputation for being the best service providers in Brazil. Caixa [the bank] needs to value, I don’t mean morally, but in terms of value, at least guaranteeing a quality of life for lottery agents. Otherwise, we’re going to end up going bankrupt,” commented Araújo.

Finally, the president of Sincoemg suggested implementing a daily game with a drawing broadcast on free-to-air TV.

The National Manager of Partner Physical Channels (GEARP), Antônio Carlos Barasuol , defended Caixa against the criticisms presented in previous panels with arguments, numbers, graphs, and the main achievements of lottery operators since 2003. Among the achievements cited were participatory management with the lottery category, the Mega-Sena jackpot ending in 5 (2003), the launch of Lotofácil (2003), adjustments to bets (2003), acceptance of payment slips from other banks (2003), withdrawals from Banco do Brasil (2004), implementation of the new technological logistics model for the lottery network (internalization) which increased the number of terminals and generated greater speed (2005), tariff realignment (2006), the second Lotofácil draw (2007), additional security (2008), implementation of Timemania (2008), and a new tariff realignment (2008).

The manager also commented on the possibility of the "end of the era of traditional bank transactions" with the increased use of the Internet for this type of service.

Barasuol stated that the solution to increasing the remuneration of the lottery network is the implementation of added services, mainly due to the large flow of people in the stores.

"Research shows that 73% of people go to a lottery outlet at least once a year," he said.

Another compelling piece of data presented by the National Manager of Partner Physical Channels, which shows that the situation for lottery retailers is not going very well, was regarding the default rate, which currently stands at R$ 300 million.

"In 2017 and 2018, the lottery concession contracts will expire and, if there are no changes in the law, there will be a bidding process," commented Barasuol.

In the panel "Overview of the Lottery Market," BNL editor Magnho José presented an overview of the lottery and gaming market in Brazil and in some countries such as the United States and Spain.

One of the topics highlighted was the issue of the low percentages of prize plans in Caixa's lotteries, which range between 28% and 32,2%, and the successful case of the Massachusetts Lottery, implemented by executive Thomas B. O'Heir, was presented.

The journalist also stressed the need for a national debate on the regulatory environment for lotteries and gambling in Brazil. Among the proposals put forward were the need to create a National and State Agency for Games and Lotteries, removing the management of games and lotteries from Caixa Econômica Federal (the Brazilian federal savings bank), reducing the interference of the National Congress in the Lottery and Gaming Service, defining the social destination of lottery prizes, defining a new payout structure for lotteries to increase the attractiveness of the products, and the creation of lotteries and video lotteries, in addition to entertainment games such as bingo, video bingo, and casinos.

The panel discussion by the Superintendent of Lotteries and Games at Caixa Econômica Federal, Roberto Derziê de Sant'Anna , was divided into five parts: World Scenario, Our Numbers, Our "Homework" (price adjustments and product positioning), New Strategic Positioning, and Timemania – New Media Plan.

Derziê stated that it is necessary to work with the National Congress to increase the payout of Caixa's lotteries. He also mentioned the need to seek new knowledge from international associations such as Cibelae, WLA, European Lotteries, AALE, APLA, and NASPL, as well as partnerships with leading global suppliers like ACE Interactive (a Swedish company providing Video Lottery Terminal Systems – VLT), GTech (a leading American IT company for lotteries and games, including terminals, networks, and processing), Stralfors (a Swedish company specializing in data transmission and logistics), and Wincor-Nixdorf (a Swedish company specializing in banking automation, lottery terminals, and points of sale).

Regarding lottery sales, the superintendent of Sualo reported that the initial target for 2008 was R$ 6,3 billion, but that this amount was projected to include the expansion of the network and the increase in lottery prices, "which have not yet been authorized by the Ministry of Finance," he said. According to Derziê, the possibility of increased inflation hampered the proposal to raise lottery prices at Caixa.

Regarding lottery sales in 2008, there was a reduction in the first quarter of 2008 compared to the same period last year. "In the first quarter of 2007, we had several Mega-Sena lottery draws with high accumulated prizes, but these numbers will be adjusted by the end of the year," explained Derziê.

Also planned for 2008 is the launch of new lottery products by Caixa, in addition to price adjustments and product positioning, which BNL will highlight in this Tuesday's edition (29).


Fire drip

At the end of the seminar "New Businesses for the Lottery Network," representatives from Caixa Econômica Federal answered questions from lottery operators.

Businessman Oliveira from the Fonte dos Milhões lottery shop (BH) asked Brasuaol if Caixa sees lottery operators "as whiners or as poor people in suits?"

Barasuol responded that “managing lottery outlets is very difficult. But Caixa sees lottery operators as great partners. Caixa could have 500 points of sale. But it has a very high level of recognition and appreciation for lottery operators. In 27 years at Caixa, I have never seen so much appreciation for lottery operators as I see today,” he commented.

When asked if he would buy a lottery outlet, Barasuol said he couldn't because he works at Caixa Econômica Federal (a Brazilian bank), but added that if it were possible, "I see it as a very attractive business, but I would buy a store with a large space to add products due to the high volume of people passing through."

Regarding the possibility of creating a Gaming Regulatory Agency, the manager of GEARP said that he has been warning lottery business owners that the creation of a Regulatory Agency "will end the lottery network in its current model."


Share: