Casino owners and Native Americans support Kamala Harris.

Casino I 03.11.24

By: Magno José

Share:
US tribal casino hit with threat of closure.
According to the National Indian Gaming Commission, in fiscal year 2023, there were 527 casinos operated by 245 Indigenous peoples in 29 American states.

Marie Spry is a woman of few words, at least with strangers. Discreet, she becomes a little more talkative when proudly describing her community's achievements ("we have a new playground for the children and it's unbelievably beautiful" or "our resource manager is intelligent, friendly, very good at what he does and really cares about the people and what happens around here"). Spry is a member of the Ojibwe, an indigenous group spread between the American state of Minnesota and Canada, reveals a report by the World Press Institute and reproduced by Estadão.

When questioned about the American elections, she is also reserved. She doesn't say who she will vote for, but mentions that if Democrats Kamala Harris and Tim Walz ("a very nice man," according to her) are elected, the current Lieutenant Governor of Minnesota, Peggy Flanagan, will become governor. This is because Walz, Kamala's running mate, is the current governor of the state.

“That would be wonderful. She is from the White Earth Nation (one of the six different groups that make up the Ojibwe people) and would be the first Indigenous woman to govern the state,” says Spry, who is part of the body responsible for administering the territory of her community (Grand Portage, another Ojibwe group).

Indigenous communities have been ignored by politicians in the US for many years because they represent only 2% of the population, according to Matthew Fletcher, a law professor at the University of Michigan and an expert on American Indian law. This, however, has been changing in recent elections, especially since 2020, as the results have become closer.

“In the states of Arizona, New Mexico, Oklahoma, North Dakota, and South Dakota, Native Americans have already changed elections for senators and governors.” Excluding Oklahoma, the majority of the Native American population supports the Democrats, given that the party tends to adopt more policies to expand reservations, explains Fletcher. There are also, however, historical reasons for this.

For many traditional American peoples, casinos are their primary source of income. Although this type of establishment is not permitted in several American states – such as Minnesota – it can be operated by indigenous populations because, according to a 1987 US Supreme Court decision, they have sovereign authority to regulate gambling businesses within their territories.

Casinos were a way for Indigenous peoples to overcome poverty, according to Thomas Klemm, a doctoral candidate in American politics specializing in Indigenous institutions at the University of Michigan. The first Indigenous establishments of this type emerged in the late 1970s, without authorization. They were initially simple bingo halls. They became more sophisticated until they attracted the attention of the government and the courts in the 80s.

Most indigenous communities, however, do not have casinos. Besides some lacking the resources to open one, many are in remote locations where they would not receive customers.

According to the National Indian Gaming Commission, in fiscal year 2023, there were 527 casinos operated by 245 Native American peoples in 29 U.S. states. That year, these operations had the highest revenue in their history: US$41,9 billion (just over R$235 billion), representing a 2,4% increase compared to 2022.

The revenue from the Grand Portage casino, for example, provides resources for community members. When they turn 18, they receive a sum of money if they have graduated from high school. "It's an amount close to US$100 (about R$565)," says Spry.

Currently, Grand Portage is home to about a thousand people, but only 300 live on the reservation. The casino is their main business.

Not all Native American casinos, however, are profitable. According to Matthew Fletcher of the University of Michigan, only 10% of these operations are actually enriching the communities. Fletcher is a member of the Grand Traverse Band, a Native American community living in northwestern Michigan that owns three casinos. Two of them are profitable.

“Life in our tribe is better now, with the casinos, than when I was a child,” says Fletcher. “Back then, there was no electricity, no water, no jobs. In 1984, the first casino opened. Ten years later, it became a profitable business.”

Before the U.S. Supreme Court ruled to authorize casinos on Native American lands, this type of business was only operated in two places in the country: Las Vegas (in Nevada) and Atlantic City (in New Jersey). Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump owned three casinos in Atlantic City and opposed the law regulating gambling on Native American reservations.

In the early 90s, Trump claimed that organized crime dominated Native American reservations and that operating casinos on those territories would destroy the industry. He also said that the Native Americans seeking licenses to open their businesses "didn't look Native American." At the time, the Los Angeles Times also reported that the then-businessman was behind a campaign that portrayed Native Americans as violent criminals and drug traffickers.

Today, however, the Republican no longer brings up the subject. In swing states where indigenous peoples represent a significant portion of the population, Trump has come to need their votes.

In Arizona, for example, Indigenous peoples make up 6% of the population. In the 2020 election, Trump received 49% of the vote there, while Joe Biden got 49,4%.

“Traditional American communities have the opportunity to make a difference again, but they also face challenges in voting,” says Fletcher. There are several debates in the country about problems translating ballots into the languages ​​of traditional peoples.

Thomas Klemm, a member of the Pokagon community of Potawatomi, whose reservation is in the state of Michigan, also states that indigenous populations have difficulty voting. In some states with large indigenous populations, such as Arizona, Oklahoma, and North Dakota, the documentation requirements at polling places are more stringent.

In Arizona, for example, presenting identification is mandatory, while in other states, such as California and New York, only a signature is used as a method of identification. Klemm points out that many indigenous people do not have documents.

“I grew up with people who don’t believe in voting because we are a sovereign nation. We vote primarily for our authorities. Regarding the federal government, there is a general dissatisfaction because historically they have never cared about us.”

In the Klemm community, there is a casino. The business is "moderately successful." "Nobody is rich, but there is enough money to offer some services to the community, such as shelter." According to him, few indigenous peoples manage to earn enough money to give a sum to young people who turn 18 – as happens among the population of Grand Portage.

Although he points out that few in his community are likely to bother voting, Klemm states that there is a perception among his people that Joe Biden showed concern for Indigenous communities by nominating Deb Haaland, an Indigenous woman, to lead the Department of the Interior. The Department of the Interior is responsible for the management and conservation of federal lands.

Gary Bohnee, the representative for legislative and congressional affairs of the Salt River Pima-Maricopa indigenous community (in Arizona), however, says that traditional peoples have learned to deal with both parties to guarantee their rights. On the one hand, he acknowledges that the Biden administration has increased the allocation of resources to indigenous populations. On the other hand, he states that Trump's statements against indigenous casinos are a thing of the past. "I don't think that still has an impact."

Bohnee refuses to say that community members have a partisan preference. “For the population, what’s important is that the politician has Indigenous interests in mind,” he says. Members of the Salt River Pima-Maricopa community, however, donated US$224 (R$1,3 million) to Democratic campaigns this year and US$89,2 (R$509) to Republicans, according to data from Open Secrets. The Salt River Pima-Maricopa people have, among their businesses, a casino, three hotels, a resort, a gas station, a baseball field, and a golf course.

Oklahoma: Oil on Indigenous Lands

In Oklahoma, the situation is different in part because some indigenous communities hold oil reserves, explains Eric Henson, a Harvard professor and researcher in the field of governance. "They tend to want legislation that supports the industry," he says.

Although the oil and gas sector has performed well under Joe Biden's administration, there is apprehension among those who depend on the sector given the Democrats' encouragement of clean energy technologies. Meanwhile, Donald Trump continues to assert that the energy transition represents a cost increase for the population and, therefore, should not be encouraged.

“There are many Native Americans in Oklahoma who vote Republican,” says Henson, who is part of the Chickasaw people, whose reservation is in the state, but has never lived in the community.

Oklahoma's own governor, Republican Kevin Stitt, is part of a traditional population, the Cherokee Nation. However, he has a conflicted relationship with several communities, both over territorial issues with the indigenous peoples and over tax rates levied on casinos.

Henson points out, however, that Oklahoma is a decided state. That is, Republicans always win there and, at least for now, there is no local contest for votes that could change the outcome.

 

Paybrokers - 728 x 90Paybrokers - 728 x 90 1

Share: