It's easier to blame the bets.

Betting , Opinion I 04.05.26

By: Magno José

Share:
Allegations of alleged bribery request should extend the Football Match-Filing Parliamentary Inquiry Commission.
Wesley Cardia*

Sports betting was legalized in Brazil in 2018 and began operating under strict government regulations starting in January 2025—less than a year and a half ago. Last year alone, online gambling operations contributed over R$ 9,95 billion in taxes and fees. And in January and February of this year alone, the tax authorities collected R$ 2,5 billion from betting sites. Could it be more? Undoubtedly, if it weren't for the thousands of illegal websites operating in Brazil without paying any taxes.

While only 87 companies operate within the strict regulations imposed by law, thousands of others—the illegal ones—do not pay taxes, accept bets from minors, engage in fraudulent advertising, frequently fail to pay prizes, have no registered office, use fraudulent CNPJs (Brazilian tax identification numbers), accept bets from citizens benefiting from numerous government social programs, and change their names when identified by the authorities. The SPA (Secretariat of Prizes and Bets) has already ordered the takedown of 27 illegal websites so far.

These two paragraphs are enough for any sensible person to understand that the problem lies in illegal gambling, not in gambling that follows all the rules. However, the gaming industry has suffered attacks from podcasts that have no idea what they're talking about, from the Legislative branch, and from the Executive branch itself, which is responsible for the laws and regulations governing the sector. Why? For reasons completely unrelated to best practices and the standards followed by companies licensed by the Ministry of Finance.

In this context, some in the National Congress are advocating for a total ban on gambling in Brazil, arguing that this would contain social and economic impacts, especially regarding mental health and the financial stability of families.

The solution, however, ignores a fundamental point: prohibition does not eliminate demand—it only displaces it. Experts and industry representatives have warned that such a measure tends to push the activity even further into illegality, reducing the State's capacity for oversight and amplifying precisely the risks it seeks to combat. Recent experiences show that regulated markets, with tax collection and control mechanisms, offer more consumer protection and generate significant public revenue, while indiscriminate repression creates space for the strengthening of already existing clandestine operations.

The attacks serve two different purposes: one is electoral. Since the government realized that public debt is bad for its image (74,7% of voters say they are concerned about the cost of living and debt, according to a Meio/Ideia survey), it decided to blame the debtors for the harmful effects of household debt. It could simply avoid increasing public debt and thus reduce interest rates. But it would be problematic, in political advertising, to explain that excessive government spending is responsible for keeping interest rates above 14%. It's easier, then, to blame the debtors.

The other group, which constantly talks about raising taxes, knows that increasing the tax burden can prevent legitimate and authorized companies from operating, because taxes are already higher than the market can bear. And I could write pages in this newspaper explaining this. What the unwary don't know, however, is that by raising taxes, life becomes more difficult for legal companies and the market is opened up even further for illegal ones—the intention of many stakeholders when they work to increase this tax burden.

Increasing the tax burden on sectors like gambling and cigarettes, for example, benefits mafias, militias, smugglers, and all those who support illegal activities. Banning betting, or suppressing it through increased taxes, only serves the interests of organized crime, because the market will be taken over by illegal gambling without any control, as in many other countries around the world.


(*) Wesley Cardia is a lawyer and former president of ANJL (National Association of Games and Lotteries). The article was published by Folha de S.Paulo.

 

Paybrokers - 728 x 90Paybrokers - 728 x 90 1

Share: