Lottery operators send letter to President Lula
The presidents of the lottery company unions in the states of São Paulo (Sincoesp), Rio de Janeiro (Sincoerj), and Santa Catarina (Sindlesc) sent a letter to the President of the Republic, Luis Inácio Lula da Silva, informing him of the risks the lottery network is facing due to problems arising from the transition of the Caixa Econômica Federal lottery system.
Letter from Sincoesp
São Paulo, August 03, 2006
EXCELLENT MR. PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC
LUIZ INÁCIO LULA DA SILVA
NEW TECHNOLOGICAL MODEL BOX
We acknowledge receipt of Your Excellency's attendance at a meeting with the president of Caixa Econômica Federal, to be held tomorrow, August 04, 2006.
It is necessary and urgent to bring to Your Excellency's attention the chaos in which the Lottery Network currently finds itself, nationwide, and to request that the aforementioned matter be included on the agenda of this meeting, with a view to making decisions that, as you can see from the reports that follow, if the delay in solving the problems prevails, will lead the Lottery Network to bankruptcy.
The implementation of the new technological model for lotteries, with the installation of new machines, has caused serious problems, since the equipment does not work and the system cannot perform all operations related to games, bill payments, and social benefit payments.
These problems encountered with the new system have already been exhaustively reported to the managers of Caixa Lotteries and those responsible for implementing the new system, such as: constant connection drops due to minor service overloads, password failures, failure to submit accounts, causing confusion in the business owner's accounting, and agreements that have not yet been included in the system. We have at the disposal of this Presidency hundreds of emails from lottery operators throughout the country reporting the various problems presented by the new system, in addition to studies conducted by specialized companies on the operational problems of the new equipment and the ergonomic problems that will manifest in the operators.
In addition to the fact that there is already some resistance from some bettors regarding placing bets on the new equipment, due to the delay in placing bets and the difficulty in receiving prizes, since it is not always possible to authenticate the prize on the machine, due to difficulties with reading the barcode, and many other issues that have already been reported to those responsible for the system.
The situation is worsening because, with the approaching end date of the contract with Gtech (August 12, 2006), almost all lottery outlets have already received the new system, leaving very few with Isys equipment (blue – Gtech), and even those few still only have one machine from the old system functioning properly and with all the agreements in place. (We possess extensive illustrative material showing the mobilization carried out by the São Paulo State Lottery Network due to the destabilization of the new system and the repercussions of these problems within the community, which is also available to Your Excellency).
Consequently, lottery operators are suffering serious losses, not to mention that cash inflow has been reduced and they are unable to pay federal government social benefits, such as school grants, family grants, PIS payments, and INSS payments.
This unstable situation with the new system, besides creating serious difficulties in service for lottery business owners, is generating great frustration among the population, since the quality of services provided is worsening every day, that is, when the population manages to be served, as the system is inoperative almost daily. To give Your Excellency a sense of the situation, the Vale do Paraíba region, in the interior of São Paulo, has had its system down since last Tuesday (August 01st), and today, August 03rd, the entire system in Brazil is paralyzed.
Much has been said, dozens of meetings have been held, but no truly concrete solution has been presented.
With each new scenario, Caixa's executives and/or directors are replaced, and new commissions are created that restart all the work again, frustrating the expectations of the lottery "partners".
We want to emphasize that this entire situation has generated a state of revolt and indignation within the Lottery Network, which today has approximately 9.000 lottery outlets throughout the country and which broadly supported Your Excellency's candidacy in the 2002 presidential elections, against the current administration of Caixa Econômica, a Federal Government company, since this same Lottery Network is considered by the majority of the population as an exemplary service provider, as can be verified by public opinion studies conducted by Caixa itself.
This dissatisfaction can be demonstrated in a survey conducted on the SINCOESP website. www.sincoesp.org.br This data reflects the preferences of voters registered in the Lottery Network for the upcoming presidential elections: as of this date, 67,7% would vote for candidate Geraldo Alckmin, 12,1% would vote for candidate Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, and 16,1% would vote for candidate Heloisa Helena.
Finally, on behalf of all Lottery Business Owners in the State of São Paulo, we implore our Supreme Commander to intercede for this category, which has always shown itself not only as a "partner" of this highly regarded entity, Caixa Econômica Federal, but also plays an important role in the lives of underprivileged communities throughout the country, as its services enable the payment of social benefits from the Federal Government and help integrate the unbanked and low-income population into the National Financial System.
Hoping to have our request granted, we await the urgent and necessary measures to stabilize the Lottery Network system.
Our regards and respect,
Luiz Carlos Peralta – President of Sincoesp
Letter from Sincoerj
Rio de Janeiro, August 03, 2006
Your Excellency Mr. President of the Republic
LUIS INÁCIO LULA DA SILVA
Dear sir,
The contract for migrating the current Caixa system expires on August 12, 2006, at which point all lottery outlets will be exclusively dependent on the Caixa system.
Caixa has not yet completed the installation in all lottery outlets, which total 9.000 locations. As of July 30th, approximately 1.000 lottery outlets still lacked the new equipment.
The problems perceived by the network can be classified as follows:
UNAVAILABILITY: The signal is non-existent or intermittent for several hours during the day, in almost all parts of the country, which is a typical problem of poor telecommunications;
SLOW RESPONSE TIME: Slowness in the electronic transaction process. Issuing a simple receipt takes at least twice as long as normal. The average time over the last 8 years is 3 to 4 seconds. The problem may lie in the transmission or processing within Caixa, which is not prepared to handle the high volume. Perhaps the processing of banking transactions is being done jointly with lottery outlets, influencing the performance of both systems.
RELIABILITY: Some transactions end up not being processed in Caixa's Central System because the financial movement reports do not match the actual movement at the lottery outlet. Software problem? Maybe.
CALL CENTER SERVICE: The number of service positions is insufficient to handle the volume of complaints and information requests. It is practically impossible to get through to Caixa's 0800 number, and when it is available, it does not provide adequate guidance.
"THE FALSE JUSTIFICATIONS THAT CAIXA HAS BEEN MAKING"
Caixa attempts to justify the problems by alleging the enormous complexity of the internalization process and the unique size of the project, but this is not true. We know that companies specializing in online lottery operations carry out dozens of migrations each year across various lotteries worldwide without experiencing problems similar to those faced by Caixa and its resellers. We also know that in 2006 alone, dozens of similar migrations were simultaneously being executed in at least 7 different countries.
These migrations often involve a complete overhaul of the operating system and terminals, such as those used by Caixa Econômica Federal (a Brazilian bank), and do not cause any disruption to the operations of these companies or even lotteries. On average, these migrations are fully completed within 12 months, as promised to the TCU (Brazilian Federal Court of Accounts) by Caixa Econômica Federal, but without causing the problems that lottery operators are facing, even being prevented from working. We know that the migration process is complex, but when carried out by specialized companies, and above all with competence and experience, the process goes smoothly.
Caixa claims that the current problems can be justified by the independence it has gained from its current supplier; however, from now on Caixa is dependent on Procomp, Vicom/Comsat, Wintech, Correios, IBM, and Politec, in addition to being dependent on the often questionable competence of its lottery system operation technicians and developers of new applications. Will life really get easier for Caixa? And for the network? To whom should lottery operators turn to make their claims? Which of the endless contracted companies will pay attention to our complaints? Your Excellency may inquire about these answers from the President of Caixa.
"QUESTIONS"
It is already known how much was spent on purchasing the Procomp terminals and how much is being spent on paying for telecommunications, consumables, and logistics services.
However, the amount invested so far to adapt Caixa's systems to process and integrate the entire system (hardware and software) and to remunerate its various suppliers, such as Call Center and developers, is still unknown. Since the initial forecast was that the system would be implemented in 12 months, it leads us to believe that, with the system still completely inoperative after 18 months of implementation, the costs have already exceeded the original project, and that these costs are being paid by lottery business owners through interest charged on their negative accounts, due to their inability to operate because of the total inoperability of the new system, resulting in the closure of many lottery outlets. To verify our statement, please provide a count of how many lottery outlets have closed during this period.
What is the value of the fines applied to defaulting suppliers? Is this amount sufficient to pay the compensation that Caixa owes to the affected lottery operators? Considering that, to date, CEF (Caixa Econômica Federal) is paying insignificant amounts, still relating to the months of March and April, and which do not even correspond to the reality of the losses caused by the shutdowns of the new system. What portion of all these problems should be attributed to Caixa itself?
Has Caixa already implemented and tested a contingency model to guarantee the continuity of services provided? If so, why doesn't it put it into practice, given that it hasn't worked since its implementation?
Who is conducting an audit at Caixa Econômica Federal (Brazilian Federal Savings Bank) to investigate the discrepancies found daily in lottery accounts, unregistered customer accounts, over- and under-debited amounts, and games processed incorrectly, such as what happened in Nova Friburgo, where the Federal Police seized Caixa's TFL (Lottery Ticket) equipment for technical examination (if Your Excellency wants proof, we can send the improperly processed ticket by fax)? Who will be held responsible for all these irregularities, which will never be reported to Your Excellency? Mr. President, someone needs to audit this process urgently.
The bidding document stipulated that the 9.000 lottery outlets in the country would have two independent networks for communication and data transmission. How many lottery outlets have more than one line? Why the frantic rush to shut down the current system when the new one isn't working? What is the real reason behind this haste, since in the first weeks of the month, no lottery outlet in Brazil is able to have consistent signals, operating and providing lottery business owners with the conditions to survive?
Mr. President, it is important that Your Excellency knows that this partnership between lottery operators and Caixa Econômica Federal (Brazilian Federal Savings Bank) is a one-sided partnership, where we receive no respect whatsoever from any employee. Currently, we are unable to cover the costs of our business, and the consequence of this is that lottery operators end up with a negative balance in their accounts, where exorbitant interest rates are charged, in the order of 13%, in addition to the traditional 0,38% CPMF (Financial Transactions Tax), which is making the business unviable every day. All of this can be seen in the number of lottery outlets that are put up for sale, and even in the reduction in their quantity, where in the recent past we had 850 fully operational lottery outlets in the State of Rio, and currently there are fewer than 740, many in a pre-bankruptcy state.
For the reasons stated, we request that you give the Presidents of Trade Unions in Brazil the opportunity to be heard by Your Excellency, so that you may have an accurate idea of the suffering of this category, which has provided so many important services to the Brazilian population.
Mr. President, with a clear conscience, knowing that we are above all exercising our right to free speech and union struggle, which is its essence, we once again ask that you listen to us and give us an opportunity. Never forget those who are on your side, those who today are the instrument for the dignified fulfillment of your social projects. For from the moment Your Excellency supports us, be assured that 40.000 lottery employees in this country, and an average of 350 customers per day, will be by your side and working directly on your reelection campaign.
Cordially,
Marcelo Furtado de Araújo – President of Sincoerj
Letter from Sindelesc
Your Excellency, Mr. President of the Republic
Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva
Lottery outlets – 2006 elections
Mr. President! The new equipment has been installed in lottery outlets since May, and it's still not working.
In every state of the Federation, there are only complaints and insults directed at the gentleman, the cashier, and the owner of the establishment.
Here in Santa Catarina, in Gaspar, the lottery operator had to call the police to restrain a citizen who was upset about not receiving his Bolsa Família payment due to the new machines being inoperable.
Mr. President, if you ask Caixa Econômica Federal, they will say that the problem is isolated.
Don't believe it! Have it checked. The courts have already granted injunctions to several lottery unions in Brazil allowing them to maintain the old machines until the new system is fully operational. São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Brasília, Bahia, Minas Gerais, and Espírito Santo were some of these states.
Mr. President! It seems they even did it on purpose to harm your reelection, since the Caixa executives already knew in advance that the new system wouldn't work. After all, they even offered to compensate lottery agents who suffered losses in their revenue due to the inoperability of the new machines.
Sir! Another regrettable fact that must also be denounced here is that, in addition to Caixa causing all this outrage among the population, who want to pay their bills and receive their benefits, and also within the lottery community that is unable to carry out its work, Caixa is, under the cover of night, distributing new machines to some favored lottery operators, without any criteria and without any discussion with the unions.
Mr. President, this is inconceivable! It's absurd! How can some people within Caixa, without democracy, without establishing criteria, favor certain lottery agents with more equipment in their stores to the detriment of the majority, and without any discussion with the representatives of the class?
Put an end to this situation! Be firm, Mr. President. Instruct Caixa to only implement the new system when they are certain it will work, and to discuss the distribution criteria for the new equipment with the unions.
Good luck, Mr. President.
Frank Paulo – President of SINDESLC – Union of Lottery Companies of the State of Santa Catarina
Your Excellency, Mr. President of the Republic
Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva
The Brazilian Federal Savings Bank (Caixa Econômica Federal) is undertaking a massive operation to replace the entire management and control system of lottery outlets, including service and betting terminals, and the system for paying social benefits.
This massive replacement of over 25 terminals is being done hastily, haphazardly, and without any concern for whether or not the new system is working.
Mr. President, the lottery outlets have become a mess! The new system doesn't work. Customers sometimes spend the whole day in line and go home without being able to pay their bills, place their bets, or receive the social benefits created by your government, including: Bolsa Escola and Bolsa Família.
Mr. President, it's heartbreaking! People from social classes "D" and "E" are the ones who most frequently visit lottery outlets. They spend hours in line, and many, unable to receive government assistance, return home empty-handed, and worse... cursing your government because they believe it's your fault.
Mr. President! Many from political parties opposed to yours are taking advantage of the situation, blaming the "Lula Government" for the chaos in the lottery outlets, which is forcing people to leave with empty pockets and sometimes without a penny at home to feed their children.
Mr. President, this lack of respect from Caixa towards the most humble is negatively influencing your government and will certainly further damage your popularity ratings.
Put an end to this situation. Instruct Caixa to only change the system when they are certain it works. The Lord cannot have enemies within his own house.
Mr. President, I wish you good elections.
Frank Paulo – President of SINDESLC – Union of Lottery Companies of the State of Santa Catarina


