"There is no protection for bets in the Chamber," says Motta regarding the Anti-Faction Bill.

In an exclusive interview with Metrópoles, the president of the Chamber of Deputies, Hugo Motta (Republicanos-PB), justified the exclusion of the Cide-Bets tax by citing the technical infeasibility of the proposal created by the Senate. Furthermore, he denied that the reason was any protection of online betting sites and stated that the decision was based on the viability of the tax.
Brazilian lawmakers approved the removal of the new tax on online betting sites through an amendment presented by the leader of the PP party, Dr. Luzinho (PP-RJ). The tax had been included in the bill by the senators. In an interview with Metrópoles, Motta defended the decision and refuted criticisms about alleged protection of the betting sector.
Motta criticized the estimated revenue from the tax. The assessment indicated that the Cide-Bets tax would generate annual revenue of R$ 30 billion. The Speaker of the House described the creation of the tax as "unfeasible." "To say that R$ 30 billion will be collected from this Cide-Bets tax is not true. Because there's a perception that, if this tax were to come into effect, it would perhaps be 10%, 15% of R$ 30 billion. Maybe all the betting sites in Brazil would generate R$ 30 billion. How do you collect R$ 30 billion from this tax?" he commented in an interview with Metrópoles.
The House believes the measure would encourage irregularities in the online betting sector . Motta highlighted that the Chamber had previously increased the tax on bets . The president further argued that the Ministry of Finance's own team had indicated the operational impossibility of collecting this type of tax, considering the current tax collection system.
At the end of last year, the Chamber approved a proposal to increase taxes on sports betting and online gaming companies. The text established a gradual increase in the tax rate, currently at 12%, to 15% in 2028. "There is no protection for bettors in the Chamber," he declared.
According to Motta, charging a tax rate considered unaffordable by the sector would end up favoring illegal betting operations , which do not pay taxes. He emphasized that, with the current regulations, the government is already able to collect taxes and access data from bettors, who are required to provide their CPF (Brazilian taxpayer ID number). "Today we have the government collecting taxes; we have the means to share and transfer data about the bettor—you have to provide your CPF—you can no longer evade taxes," he explained.
“In no way did we want to protect betting . We faced the debate honestly, and the Chamber's decision was to remove this tax that was put in place in the Senate, precisely for that reason, due to technical incompatibility, because we had already increased the tax on betting , and so as not to favor the illegality of a sector that is beginning to legalize in the country,” he stated.
The Speaker of the House declared that "There is no protection for betting companies in the House." Motta explained that the decision was based on the viability of the tax and the technical incompatibility of the proposal. He reinforced that the House approved, at the end of last year, an increase in the tax collection on betting companies , demonstrating that there is no intention to protect the sector.
The Chamber's decision was to highlight an independent proposal. This mechanism opens the possibility of creating the Cide-bets through a new, separate bill.
The measure received criticism from parliamentarians from the government's base. The rapporteur of the project in the Senate, Alessandro Vieira (MDB-SE), included the Cide-Bets tax in the text. Vieira lamented the decision of the Chamber of Deputies.
Watch the video as the Speaker of the House defends the House measure that removed the tax on bets from the Anti-Faction Bill.
Igor Gadelha: Mr. President, let's begin then with these issues you mentioned. Ah, the anti-gang bill was approved, but the creation of the so-called CideBets, which would be a contribution from betting companies that would finance the fight against organized crime, was removed from the text at the last minute by an amendment from the Progressives party. Isn't it a contradiction for the Chamber, in this discourse of combating organized crime, to remove a tax that would be used to combat organized crime? Why was it removed at the last minute and in a symbolic vote?
Hugo Motta: Igor, it's necessary to put things in their proper place. The creation of this CideBet tax is precisely in line with what we cannot oppose, which is stronger funding for public security. The only thing that needs to be honest about is the feasibility of collecting this tax. It's important to say that the Chamber of Deputies approved an increase in taxes on betting at the end of the year. So there is no protection for betting in the Chamber of Deputies. This discourse is not true.
Hugo Motta: The inclusion of the CideBet tax by the Senate is, firstly, unfeasible from a collection standpoint. The Ministry of Finance's own team says that it's impossible to collect this type of tax on betting operations. The current system for collecting taxes simply doesn't allow for it. Secondly, saying that billions of reais will be collected with this tax is untrue—perhaps 10 or 15% of 30 billion would be collected, if that; it's an unrealistic estimate. First, we increased the tax on betting. Second, the government's technical team deemed the operationalization of this tax impossible. And thirdly, and most seriously, we would be favoring illegal betting. Why? Because if you charge a rate that is impossible for a sector to pay, you favor illegality and the consolidation within the sector of those who pay no tax at all. Today we have the government collecting taxes; We have the means to share and transfer data about the bettor—you have to provide your CPF (Brazilian tax identification number)—so you can no longer evade taxes. Therefore, in no way did we intend to protect betting; we approached the debate honestly, and the Chamber's decision was to remove this tax that was introduced in the Senate precisely because of technical incompatibility, because we had already increased the tax on betting, and to avoid favoring illegality in a sector that is beginning to legalize.


