Brazilian Supreme Court (STF): Law requiring armed security in lottery outlets is unconstitutional.

Lottery I 12.06.20

By: Elaine Silva

Share:
The decision takes free competition into account (Photo: Carlos Vieira/CB/DA Press)
The Brazilian Supreme Court ruled on ADI (Direct Action of Unconstitutionality) 4861, concerning the district law that mandated the hiring of armed security by lottery outlets, banking correspondents, and similar businesses. In its decision, the Supreme Court stated that the "direct action of unconstitutionality was deemed admissible." The action was brought by the Union of Lottery, Commissioned, and Consigned Companies of the Federal District.
Among the arguments raised in the decision, it was considered that the objective of the law was to guarantee the safety of service users; however, "the matter falls within the scope of concurrent jurisdiction between the Union, the State, and the Federal District." The decision also took into account the disruption of free competition and highlighted that the measure requires the hiring of highly specialized private security, which entails costs and would prevent access to companies that do not offer this type of service.
The decision also highlights that there are differences in remuneration for each company, depending on the service provided, and that a uniform measure for all would harm companies with simpler activities.
Another point raised is that the chaos in public security cannot be attributed solely to lottery outlets, bank correspondents, or credit unions and similar establishments. Nor can they be held responsible for "restoring public security." Furthermore, the law violates the principles of reasonableness and proportionality by restricting the measure to this sector, when other areas also handle large sums of money.Mail Braziliense – Brasília – DF)

Share: