Comsefaz attributes R$ 40,4 billion to betting companies based on data that the Central Bank itself says it does not have.

The National Committee of State Finance Secretaries (Comsefaz) has once again attributed a billion-dollar figure to betting transactions. In the 4th edition of the Brazilian States' Fiscal Bulletin, additional net transfers via Pix associated with betting totaled R$ 40,39 billion from January to July 2026, a figure the publication rounds to R$ 40,4 billion. Using the same concept, the bulletin calculates R$ 62,48 billion in 2025 and a monthly average of R$ 4,85 billion between October 2024 and July 2026. The study was conducted with the Celso Furtado International Center (Cicef) and presented live on YouTube.
The bulletin states that it uses payment statistics from the Central Bank. On the same day of the announcement, the Central Bank responded to BNLData, in response to a request under the Access to Information Law, stating that it does not monitor Pix payments for betting sites. The two facts do not add up.
Comsefaz vs. Central Bank
The Central Bank of Brazil (BC) indicated to BNLData the Statistics on Payments by Economic Activity (EPAE). This statistic does not separate betting: it is included in section R of the National Classification of Economic Activities (CNAE), along with arts, museums, zoos, and sporting activities. In the appeal hearing, the BC confirmed that the EPAE does not have a breakdown for division 92 (gambling and betting) and that Special Study No. 119/2024, from September 2024, is the only one it has conducted on the subject. After that, the BC only performed a "simple routine" at the beginning of 2025, shortly after the publication of the list of authorized companies, and found average receipts of R$ 18 billion to R$ 21 billion per month. There are no other studies, completed or in progress, and the BC does not have data for 2026. The BC itself warned that these values are gross transfers, that is, what was wagered and not what was lost, because part of the money returns as a prize.
In other words: the payment data comes from the Central Bank, but the Central Bank doesn't say how much of that money went to the betting sites. That calculation was done using a model from Comsefaz (the tax authority).
Which series did Comsefaz use?
The series refers to Pix transfers from individuals to companies in the "arts, culture, sports and recreation" segment of EPAE. The bulletin itself acknowledges, on page 40, that the difference between the observed value and the projection "does not, in itself, constitute a precise causal estimate of the effect of bets," because the segment includes other activities. This caveat has disappeared from the headlines.
In the presentation on November 5th, economist Flávio Arantes, from Comsefaz, went further. He said that the researchers "assumed" that the increase in Pix (Brazilian instant payment system) was linked to online betting and that, with the prohibition, it would be "very likely" to be able to "confirm this hypothesis." In the words of those who conducted the study, therefore, it is a hypothesis still without confirmation. Even so, according to the presenters themselves, the number "became a national reference" and reached the Supreme Court.
There is another discrepancy. In 2025, the additional gross volume that Comsefaz attributes to betting companies averaged R$ 29,2 billion per month (R$ 350,97 billion for the year). This is 39% to 62% above the range of R$ 18 billion to R$ 21 billion that the Central Bank itself found when measuring the receipts of authorized companies at the beginning of that year.
What is "additional net transfer"?
It is the difference between the observed balance (payments from families to the segment minus what they received from it) and a counterfactual: a projection made with an ARIMA model based on data up to August 2024. This is where the main problem with the number lies.
Before the bets, the balance was negative, meaning families received more than they paid. In August 2024, the balance was -R$ 1,1 billion. The model projects this negative pattern for the following months and counts everything above it as the "effect of the bets." Thus, the total also includes the money that families, according to the projection, would have received but did not.
The result is reflected in the bulletin's own figures. The highest net balance observed in the entire series was R$ 5,3 billion in January 2025, which the document calls the "series peak." But the average attributed to bets between January and July 2026 is R$ 5,77 billion per month. This estimate is higher than any month actually recorded, showing that part of the value comes from the model and not from Pix.
The 2026 figures also don't add up. The additional gross volume fell from R$ 29,2 billion to R$ 20,6 billion per month (-30%) from 2025 to 2026, but the net amount attributed to bets rose from R$ 5,2 billion to R$ 5,8 billion (+11%). The report doesn't explain why. Furthermore, the series doesn't differentiate between authorized companies and illegal sites, nor does it distinguish between balances left in bettors' wallets and lost money.
How does this number compare to SPA's official GGR?
GGR (gross gaming revenue) is the amount wagered minus the prizes paid out. It is the official measure of what bettors have lost in the regulated market, and the bulletin does not mention it. The Comsefaz text on the study does not mention GGR or SPA.
According to data obtained by BNLData via LAI (Law on Access to Information), the GGR (Gross Revenue from Betting) for the first half of 2026 was R$ 20,07 billion, 15,3% higher than the same period in 2025. In the same semester, R$ 377,86 billion returned to bettors in prizes. The monthly average was R$ 3,35 billion. The Comsefaz (National Council of Finance Secretaries) monthly average for 2026 (R$ 5,77 billion) is 72% higher than the official figure.
The same thing happens in 2025. The regulated market billed R$ 37 billion that year, and the R$ 62,48 billion from Comsefaz is 69% higher. From the GGR, society also received a share: R$ 2,49 billion went to public policies and social purposes in the first half of 2026, equivalent to 12,4% of the GGR. These resources go to the legal beneficiaries and do not appear in any counterfactual.
ANJL has already challenged the previous edition.
The 2025 figure was questioned as soon as it was released. The National Association of Games and Lotteries (ANJL) refuted the information that families would have lost R$ 62,5 billion to betting in 2025. The entity cited the SPA's GGR of R$ 37 billion, 40% lower than the value in the bulletin. ANJL also pointed out that greater access to digital banking services has led to the growth of Pix in various sectors. Until then, Comsefaz had not publicly responded to the criticisms. In the 4th edition, the method remains the same.
In the same presentation, the institutional director of Comsefaz, André Horta, presented as evidence the ABRAS thesis that consumption in supermarkets increased with the end of betting, another claim that has no proof. A study that admits to not measuring causality has come to support a causal conclusion. Gambling is either legal or illegal; not gambling is impossible. What the report measures, for sure, is the Pix (Brazilian currency) of an entire segment of the economy, and not the losses of bettors.


