A month after the announcement, the Treasury Department has not said how much it has returned to bettors.

Bets I 20.11.26

By: Magno José

Share:
A month after the announcement, the Treasury Department has not said how much it has returned to bettors.
In response to the BNLData LAI (Law on Access to Information), SPA used the entire extension period, left six of the seven questions regarding the restitution of balances unanswered, and, regarding the fight against illegal websites, reported how many addresses it sent for blocking, not how many were actually blocked.

A month after Secom announced that R$ 159 million remained to be returned to bettors, the Ministry of Finance does not know, or does not want to say, how much of that money went back into the pockets of those who had balances in betting houses. This is shown in the response from the Secretariat of Prizes and Bets (SPA) to the information request from BNLData, presented on October 11 based on the Access to Information Law (LAI) and answered this Tuesday (November 10).

The request referenced the Secom press release of October 10th regarding the restitution of balances foreseen in article 9 of Provisional Measure No. 1.394/2026, which prohibited fixed-odds betting in the country. On October 5th, the balance to be returned was estimated at R$ 1,2 billion. Five days later, Secom mentioned R$ 159 million. BNLData asked the Treasury:

⇒ the calculation breakdown for the reduction from R$1,2 billion to R$159 million;

⇒ the name and CNPJ (Brazilian tax ID) of the eight companies that did not send data to the banks, along with the estimated balance of each one;

⇒ if the R$ 159 million includes the balances of these eight companies;

⇒ How much has actually been refunded, to how many bettors, and into how many accounts;

⇒ the cost of the refund operation and who pays for it;

⇒ The rules for this phase at Caixa Econômica Federal: deadline, application channel, and destination of unclaimed funds;

⇒ How many websites submitted for blocking between September 25th and October 9th were actually blocked, day by day?

One sentence for six questions.

The original deadline expired on November 3rd. On that day, the Treasury extended the response by another ten days, "due to complexity." The response arrived classified as "access partially granted," under the justification that part of the information is "related to an ongoing decision-making process."

For the six items regarding the refund, however, SPA wrote only one sentence: the data “is currently being processed.” There is no calculation breakdown, company names, amount refunded, number of bettors served, cost of the operation, or rules for the Caixa stage. The items regarding cost and Caixa are not even mentioned.

The response itself contradicts itself. After justifying the partial denial, SPA states at the end that "there is no personal information or information protected by other confidentiality provisions in this statement." The number that BNLData wants to understand is also not under internal discussion: it was released by the government itself, in an official press release, a month ago.

Sending is not blocking

The only question answered with numbers was that of blocked sites, and even then, not how it was done. BNLData requested the number of websites actually blocked. SPA reported how many URLs it forwarded to Anatel for blocking by telecommunications operators:

One month after the announcement, the Treasury Department has not said how much it has returned to bettors.

The numbers measure the effort of sending the data, not the result. The table doesn't say how many addresses actually went offline. It also doesn't say how many websites were involved, since a single domain can have multiple URLs. Furthermore, SPA didn't indicate that Anatel would be the data holder, as required by the LAI (Brazilian Access to Information Law).

The table has gaps: no submissions on September 25th, the date the Provisional Measure was published, nor on October 5th, the Monday on which the deadline for bettors to withdraw their balances ended. After a peak of 2.678 URLs on September 29th, the volume stabilized at around 1.500 per day. This rate suggests a constant replenishment of addresses by illegal operators, as indicated by LegitBet reports released by ANJL.

What the government has not yet shown

The Finance Ministry's response completes the picture of the requests that BNLData presented on October 11th, the same day it published the FactCheck "Government report on betting hides more than it reveals". The Central Bank responded without providing data, and the Ministry of Justice and Public Security has also already responded. None of the three bodies reported how much was actually returned to bettors or how much was recovered from illegal platforms.

BNLData appealed SPA's response and submitted a request for information to Anatel regarding the blocks that were actually implemented.

Paybrokers - 728 x 90Paybrokers - 728 x 90 1

Share: