Government prepares rules for taxing online betting; expected date is April.

Bets I 20.03.23

By: Magno José

Share:
The government has not yet announced what type of taxation will be implemented or what the rates will be, but the Finance Minister, Fernando Haddad, has already indicated that it will likely come through a contribution rather than a tax.

The Ministry of Finance is working to begin taxing the sports betting website sector, which generates billions and is currently exempt from any type of taxation in Brazil. The "betting" market, as it is called, was legalized in 2018 through a decree signed by then-President Michel Temer (PMDB-SP). However, almost five years later, its activities are still not regulated.

Online sports betting allows users to place bets on everything from local football teams to international basketball teams. The sector is experiencing a boom in growth and has begun sponsoring almost all major football teams, both men's and women's. The BNL Data portal, specializing in the gaming market, estimates that this market will generate R$ 12 billion in revenue in 2023, a 71% increase compared to the R$ 7 billion earned in 2020.

Current law only allows apps to operate in the country if they are based abroad, have no physical points of sale, and operate on international internet domains. The new regulation will require companies to be based in Brazil – since they are currently located outside the country – improving oversight, revenue collection, and communication with agents operating in the sector.

The taxation is expected to be implemented through a provisional measure next month. The government has not yet announced what type of taxation will be implemented or what the rates will be, but the Finance Minister, Fernando Haddad, has already indicated that it will likely be through a contribution rather than a tax. It is expected that the taxation will be applied to the gross profits of companies and the licenses they need to operate. Players would also have their winnings taxed under Income Tax, but the ministry has not yet decided on the exemption bracket or the percentage that will be charged on prizes.

Economist Rica Mello pointed out that Brazil is one of the few countries that does not tax online betting. “This market is taxed in many other countries, and there is room for such taxation here. Games organized by the government through lotteries, such as Mega-Sena and Lotofácil, all pay a percentage close to 30% when the bettor wins, and this is a significant amount of government revenue. So much so that there has been discussion that taxing online betting could mean up to R$ 8 billion in revenue per year,” he stated.

The ministry's intention with the tax is precisely to increase revenue, to compensate for losses from the announced changes in the Income Tax table. "This tax will probably be somewhere between 10% and 20% of the bettor's prize money, and of course, there is a danger that bettors will place their bets with companies outside of Brazil, because some other countries do not levy these taxes," Mello assessed.

Support from the sector

Contrary to expectations, the news was well received in the gaming sector, which has been trying for decades to legalize and expand the private betting market in the country. This is because taxation will come along with the regulation of the service, which will bring more legal certainty and business potential. With the regulation approved, analysts expect the sector to gain around R$ 20 billion in annual revenue, generating R$ 700 million annually for the National Treasury.

According to businessman and sports trader Antônio Mandarrari, CEO of the betting company Lance 365, the discussion surrounding the issue has been ongoing for several years, since the closure of bingo halls during the first term of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's (PT) government. He believes that with legislation for the sector, betting will become more transparent.

"Given the current economic scenario in Brazil, a very important point in this discussion about regulation is that the activity will begin to receive conventional tax revenue and will contribute to job creation, directly impacting the advancement of our economy," explained the businessman.

"A large part of society is unaware of the state of the sector. Companies are authorized to operate in the country, but because it is not a regulated activity, they are all based abroad, and the tax burdens are not collected by the Brazilian government," added Mandarrari.

Lottery outlets have also shown interest in regulation. The president of the Brazilian Federation of Lottery Companies (Febralot), Jodismar Amaro, stated that lotteries are seeking participation in the online segment. “As soon as the provisional measure is released, we will submit a project to seek participation, so that lottery outlets can be included and we can also offer this type of service. There are 13 lottery outlets in Brazil; we already have the network ready and we want to be included in some way,” he said.

Security for the bettor

Given the expectations surrounding the taxation, people who use the extra income to gamble are keeping a close eye on what might happen. Gabriel Rocha, 24, withdrew all the money he had in betting sites while the imbroglio remains unresolved, as he fears that something might go wrong and users would have to foot the bill. Since the middle of last year, the advertising professional decided to invest in this market.

He set aside R$1.500, part for betting and part for joining groups that give advice on which games to invest in. By February, Gabriel had already managed to profit R$4. “The secret is not to risk too much. The people who give advice on what to bet on know a lot about what they do, so I usually mix their guidance with my gut feeling and then just hope for the best,” said the young man.

Regarding the issue of regulation and potential taxation, he says he intends to take a break from gambling, but wants to return in the future. “It was an investment I made that paid off. Obviously, I can lose money when I bet wrong, but that's part of it. Now I'll wait to see what happens in court, because I'm afraid they'll freeze my account and I won't be able to recover my money. I hope this gets resolved as soon as possible,” Gabriel hopes.

As the law stands today, bettors would pay 30% of the winnings, the same as a winner of lotteries operated by Caixa Econômica Federal (Brazil's state-owned bank). According to sports lawyer Luciano Andrade Pinheiro, partner at Corrêa da Veiga Advogados, if the regulation maintains the lottery percentage, the sector will be harmed. "This needs to change urgently. If the government maintains this percentage, bettors will have no incentive to access regular Brazilian websites and will continue betting abroad via the internet," he assessed.

Student Arthur de Andrade, 22, has already had his experiences in the betting market and, unlike Gabriel, doesn't plan to return. He started in the betting business out of curiosity. “I saw some people making a lot of money with bets that seemed obvious, so I thought I could do it too. As soon as I had some extra money, I set aside some and started betting,” said the young man, who started betting with R$ 80 and ended up making almost R$ 2.

Having won a lot of money in a short period of time, the student believes he harmed himself in other ways. “It went to my head. I lost hours of my day researching what to bet on and following the results of the games. Even though I thought I was aware of what I was doing and that it was just a hobby, deep down it became an addiction; I always wanted to bet and try to win more, I even lost a thousand reais in one day. Fortunately, I was able to realize this before losing something important to me,” he reported.

Lawyer Gerlio Figueiredo, a member of the Brazilian Institute of Criminal Sciences, highlighted the importance of taxation, which should bring more security to bettors. “It is indeed important to tax these companies; they are coming from abroad and making billions, and the only one not getting anything from it is the government. Furthermore, regulation should generate more security for users. Thousands of Brazilians place these bets, but they don't have security because these companies are not licensed in the country. When any kind of problem occurs, there is no one to turn to,” he said.

According to the expert, with regulation, websites will operate legally in Brazil, with a CNPJ (Brazilian tax ID), headquarters, employees, paying taxes and generating income. "Without regulation, as it is today, companies operate abroad and do business here, without generating any direct benefit to the country," Figueiredo highlighted. ( Correio Braziliense – DF)

 


Share: